"1421: El año que China descubrió el mundo" by Gavin Menzies is an intriguing and thought-provoking historical book that challenges conventional ideas about early exploration. Menzies presents a compelling argument that China, rather than Western civilizations, was the true pioneer of global exploration.
Throughout the book, Menzies takes readers on a captivating journey, delving into the evidence and theories surrounding China's alleged expeditions in the 15th century. The author uses detailed maps, historical documents, and scientific research to support his claim, showcasing his meticulous research and attention to detail.
What sets "1421" apart from other historical books is Menzies' ability to engage and captivate readers. His writing style is accessible and entertaining, making it easy for readers to absorb complex historical information. He also adds a personal element to the narrative by sharing anecdotes, which adds a human touch and further enhances the reading experience.
Available on Audible
One of the strengths of this book is Menzies' ability to challenge established historical accounts. He questions the commonly accepted narrative of Western exploration and provides alternative explanations that revolve around Chinese exploration. This fresh perspective shines a new light on a period of history that has long been dominated by a Eurocentric viewpoint.
Overall, "1421: El año que China descubrió el mundo" is a compelling and thought-provoking read for history enthusiasts. Menzies presents a well-researched argument that challenges traditional views of early exploration. Whether one agrees with his theories or not, the book offers a fascinating and engaging alternative perspective on world history. It encourages readers to question established narratives and consider the possibility that history may be more complex and multifaceted than previously believed.
What are readers saying?
Gavin Menzies' book, "1421: El año que China descubrió el mundo" (1421: The Year China Discovered the World), has received a mix of reviews from readers. The book delves into the controversial theory that Vice-Admiral Zheng He and the Chinese fleet actually discovered America and other parts of the world before Christopher Columbus.
Some readers appreciate Menzies' extensive research and compelling arguments, finding the book thought-provoking. They praise the author's efforts to shed light on a lesser-known aspect of history and his ability to present complex information in an engaging manner. These readers believe the book is accessible to both history enthusiasts and casual readers.
However, others criticize Menzies, highlighting his lack of evidence and reliance on speculation. They argue that his theory lacks solid support from scholarly research and dismiss it as mere speculation or a conspiracy theory. Critics claim that Menzies selectively chooses evidence that aligns with his theory while disregarding contradictory information.
Some readers also express frustration with the book's organization and writing style. They find it repetitive and disjointed, making it challenging to follow the author's arguments. Additionally, a few readers question Menzies' credibility due to his tendency to make grandiose claims without providing sufficient evidence.
Several reviewers mention that the translation of the book from English to Spanish is subpar, with awkward phrasing and grammatical errors present throughout the text. This affects the reading experience and may hinder comprehension for some Spanish-speaking readers.
#1421ElOqueChinaDescubrióElMundo #ChineseExploration #GlobalDiscovery