2005 Terrorist Detainee Abuse And Torture Allegations: Military Reports And Documents On Enemy Combatant Interrogations, Abu Ghraib And Guantanamo (Dvd Rom) : Book Review

"2005 Terrorist Detainee Abuse and Torture Allegations" is an in-depth exploration of the troubling allegations and investigations of detainee abuse by the U.S. government. The author's meticulous research and analysis shed light on a dark chapter in American history, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of this controversial topic.

Through a careful examination of the specific incidents and the legal and moral dilemmas they raise, the author presents a detailed account of the allegations. This thoroughness allows readers to delve into the complexities surrounding the issue and form their own informed opinions.

One notable strength of this book lies in its examination of the investigations carried out by a range of entities, including government agencies, non-governmental organizations, and international bodies. By providing an extensive overview of these investigations, the author highlights both their successes and shortcomings, contributing to a more nuanced understanding of the issue at hand.

Moreover, the book delves into the policy decisions and directives that shaped the treatment of detainees, uncovering the systemic factors that facilitated the alleged abuses. Through an exploration of the legal framework in place at the time, the author delves into the justifications and interpretations that underpinned certain practices.

In summary, "2005 Terrorist Detainee Abuse and Torture Allegations" is a thought-provoking and extensively researched book that provides a comprehensive overview of this contentious subject. The author's balanced approach and inclusion of various perspectives make it an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to grasp the complexities surrounding detainee abuse and torture allegations in the United States.

What are readers saying?

The book titled "2005 Terrorist Detainee Abuse and Torture Allegations" by the U.S. Government has garnered a range of responses from readers. This compilation presents the results of an inquiry into claims of detainee abuse and torture by the U.S. military during the War on Terror.

Some reviewers praised the book's comprehensive approach, applauding it for offering a detailed account of the investigation's findings. They commended its objectivity and thoroughness, noting that it provided valuable insights into the controversial practices carried out by the U.S. government. Many found the book informative, attributing it with shedding light on a critical issue.

However, not all readers were convinced by the book's credibility and perceived it to be biased. Critics raised concerns about the U.S. government's involvement in the investigation, suspecting that it may have influenced the report's conclusions. These individuals argued that the book failed to present a balanced perspective, as it appeared to disproportionately absolve the government and downplay allegations of abuse and torture.

Furthermore, some reviewers expressed dissatisfaction with the book's writing style and organization. They found it to be dry and overly bureaucratic, which hindered their ability to engage with the material. These readers believed that the book lacked a human element, making it difficult to empathize with the detainees and comprehend the impact their alleged abuses had on them and their families. Consequently, they felt disconnected from the subject matter.

Moreover, certain reviewers questioned the book's relevance, particularly in relation to subsequent revelations and investigations into detainee abuse. They argued that the book provided a limited and outdated perspective, overshadowed by more recent and substantial reports on the topic.

TerroristDetaineeAbuse TortureAllegations HumanRightsViolation