A Break with Charity: A Story about the Salem Witch Trials : Book Review

"A Break with Charity" by Ann Rinaldi is a captivating historical fiction novel that takes place in the town of Salem during the infamous witch trials of 1692. The story revolves around the life of Susannah North Martin, a young girl who becomes entangled in the chaos and madness of the witch hunts. Rinaldi's writing skillfully brings to life the fear and paranoia that consumed Salem during this dark period, immersing the reader in the sights, sounds, and emotions of the 17th century.

What sets this book apart is Rinaldi's attention to detail and thorough research. Her vivid descriptions and meticulous depiction of the era make it feel as though the reader has been transported back in time. The narrative is filled with suspense, betrayal, and courage, captivating readers from start to finish.

Susannah North Martin is a compelling protagonist, facing numerous challenges and moral dilemmas. Rinaldi delves into her inner struggles, exploring her beliefs, the accusations against her, and the loyalty of those close to her. This adds layers of depth to the story, allowing readers to empathize with Susannah and the difficult choices she must make.

Another strength of Rinaldi's writing is her ability to humanize historical figures. The accused witches are portrayed as multi-dimensional characters, going beyond the role of mere victims. This adds complexity and nuance to the narrative, highlighting the intricacies of human nature even in times of mass hysteria.

Ultimately, "A Break with Charity" is a thought-provoking novel that sheds light on a dark period in American history. Rinaldi's storytelling skillfully transports readers to Salem, allowing them to experience the tension, fear, and injustice of the witch trials. The book raises important questions about prejudice, justice, and the dangerous consequences of unchecked paranoia.

What are readers saying?

"A Break with Charity" by Ann Rinaldi has garnered a range of reactions from readers. Some reviewers have praised the book for its captivating storytelling and accurate depiction of history, while others have expressed concerns about the pacing and development of the characters.

Many readers have appreciated the book's historical context, which effectively transports them back to the time of the Salem witch trials. They have commended Ann Rinaldi for her meticulous research and attention to detail, which contribute to the authenticity of the story. The vivid descriptions of the era have also been applauded for immersing readers in the time period.

Opinions on the character development in "A Break with Charity" have been divided. Some readers have found the protagonist, Susanna English, relatable and have admired her strength and resilience. However, others have felt that the characters lack depth and fail to fully resonate with the readers.

The pacing of the novel has also been a point of contention among readers. While some have found the book fast-paced, with suspenseful moments that kept them engrossed, others have criticized the uneven pacing, which included slow sections that disrupted the flow of the story.

Many readers have appreciated the book's exploration of themes such as prejudice and the dangers of mob mentality. They have found it thought-provoking and relevant to contemporary society, drawing parallels between the witch trials and modern-day injustices. This thematic depth adds an extra layer of significance to the narrative.

ABreakWithCharity HistoricalFiction SalemWitchTrials