Benjamin A. Elman's book, "A Cultural History of Modern Science in China," provides a detailed and comprehensive overview of the development of science in China from the 17th to the 21st century. Through a multidisciplinary approach, Elman explores the complex cultural and historical factors that shaped the growth of scientific knowledge in China.
One of the notable strengths of Elman's work is his examination of the cultural context in which scientific progress took place. He delves into the ways in which traditional Chinese knowledge systems, such as Confucianism and Daoism, interacted with Western scientific ideas. This analysis reveals the intricate process by which Chinese scholars sought to integrate these two bodies of knowledge, leading to the dynamic and evolving nature of scientific thought in China.
In addition, Elman emphasizes the social and political dimensions of scientific development. He explores how government policies, international collaboration, and global scientific networks influenced the advancement of science in China. This perspective provides readers with a comprehensive understanding of the larger socio-political forces that shaped scientific institutions and the dissemination of knowledge.
Available on Audible
What sets Elman's book apart is his engaging and accessible writing style. His clear and concise explanations make this book approachable for both academics and general readers. By unraveling the complex relationship between Chinese culture and the development of science, Elman offers a nuanced portrayal of the challenges and achievements of Chinese scientists throughout history.
Overall, Benjamin A. Elman's "A Cultural History of Modern Science in China" is a valuable contribution to the field of Chinese science studies. By examining the cultural, social, and political dimensions of science in China, Elman provides a comprehensive and insightful account that sheds light on the intricacies of scientific development in a non-Western context. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the history and cultural dynamics of scientific progress in China.
What are readers saying?
"A Cultural History of Modern Science in China" by Benjamin A. Elman has garnered a wide range of responses from readers. While some commend the book for its meticulous research and insightful analysis, others criticize its dense and convoluted prose, making it challenging to comprehend.
Those who praise Elman's work applaud the depth of information presented in the book. They appreciate the author's expertise on the subject matter and the well-founded historical context that is provided. The book is seen as an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to understand the cultural influences on the development of science in China.
However, there are criticisms regarding the book's writing style. Some reviewers find the text to be overly dense and scholarly. They mention that the author's long and complex sentences make it difficult to follow the material. Additionally, Elman assumes a certain level of prior knowledge, making it challenging for readers less familiar with Chinese history or science to fully grasp the content.
In addition to the writing style, readers also note issues with the organization and structure of the book. Some mention that it feels disjointed and lacks a clear narrative thread, which hampers their engagement with the material and the author's arguments.
Despite these critiques, there are still readers who highly recommend the book for its unique perspective on the cultural history of science in China. They value Elman's nuanced approach and believe that the book offers valuable insights into how science developed within a specific cultural context.
ModernScienceInChina ChineseScientificLegacy CulturalHistoryOfScience