A Historical Commentary on Thucydides: Volume 2: The Ten Years' War Books II-III : Book Review

"A Historical Commentary on Thucydides" written by A.W. Gomme is a remarkable scholarly work that extensively explores the historical context and analysis of Thucydides' renowned historical account of the Peloponnesian War. Gomme's expertise in ancient history is evident in this comprehensive and insightful commentary.

The book commences with an introduction that provides crucial background information on Thucydides and his work. Gomme then delves into a detailed examination of each book of Thucydides' history, offering a wealth of commentary and analysis. By thoroughly dissecting the text, Gomme brings to light key themes, political events, and military strategies, allowing readers to truly engage with the material.

One notable aspect of Gomme's commentary is his ability to integrate archaeological findings and other historical sources, effectively enhancing the reader's understanding of the period. Gomme's meticulous research and attention to detail permeate throughout the book. Additionally, he addresses various interpretations and debates surrounding the meaning and significance of Thucydides' work, providing readers with a well-rounded view of the scholarly discourse surrounding this historical period.

Although the book is undoubtedly scholarly, Gomme's writing style remains accessible and engaging. He strikes a fine balance between academic rigor and readability, making it suitable for both experts and newcomers to Thucydides' work. His explanations are clear, and his arguments are well-supported, making this commentary a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of this significant historical period.

In conclusion, "A Historical Commentary on Thucydides" by A.W. Gomme stands as an exceptional resource for individuals interested in Thucydides' historical account of the Peloponnesian War. Gomme's extensive knowledge and insightful commentary make this book an essential companion for both scholars and enthusiasts alike. It is a meticulously researched and well-written work that sheds light on the complexities of Thucydides' texts and the historical events they describe.

What are readers saying?

"A Historical Commentary on Thucydides" by A.W. Gomme has received a variety of reviews from readers. While many readers appreciate the thorough analysis and valuable insights provided by the author, some find the book difficult to follow or lacking in readability.

Numerous readers commend Gomme for his extensive knowledge and expertise in the subject matter. They appreciate the comprehensive commentary on Thucydides' historical work, which enhances their understanding of the text. Additionally, readers find the author's analysis to be thought-provoking and illuminating, shedding new light on various aspects of Thucydides' work.

However, there are some readers who struggle with the book. They mention that the writing style is excessively dry and academic, making it challenging for non-experts to fully grasp the content. Additionally, a few readers find the commentary to be convoluted and difficult to navigate, which hampers their overall reading experience.

It is worth noting that Gomme's book may be more suitable for those with prior knowledge or a strong interest in Thucydides and ancient history. These readers find the detailed analysis and scholarly approach to be engaging and rewarding.

On the other hand, there are readers who feel that the book lacks readability due to its heavy use of academic jargon and complex language. They express a desire for a more accessible writing style that would make the content easier to understand for a wider audience.

ThucydidesCommentary HistoricalInsights AncientHistory