A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America : Book Review

"A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America" by Peter Steinfels is a captivating exploration of the challenges and controversies encountered by the Catholic Church in the United States. Steinfels, an esteemed journalist and former editor of Commonweal magazine, presents a comprehensive analysis of the issues that impact the Church and its followers in contemporary times.

The book delves into a wide array of topics, including the decline in Catholic religious practices, the devastating sexual abuse scandals that have shaken the foundations of the Church, the growing divide between conservative and liberal Catholics, and the influence of cultural and social changes on Catholic communities. Steinfels approaches these intricate issues with great depth and nuance, offering historical context and engaging in thoughtful analysis.

One of the standout aspects of this book is Steinfels' balanced approach. He provides a fair and objective examination of the various perspectives within the Catholic Church, skillfully avoiding bias or the promotion of any specific agenda. This allows readers to form their own opinions and gain a deeper understanding of the complexity of the issues at hand.

Steinfels astutely incorporates personal stories and experiences from Catholics across the country, giving voice to the struggles and concerns of everyday individuals. By humanizing the larger issues, he brings them closer to readers who may not be familiar with the intricacies of Catholicism, making them more relatable and relatable.

Overall, "A People Adrift" offers a thorough and insightful examination of the challenges faced by the Roman Catholic Church in America. It serves as a valuable resource for anyone interested in comprehending the current state of Catholicism in the United States and contemplating potential paths forward for the Church and its faithful followers. With its thought-provoking analysis and wealth of information, this book is sure to leave readers with a deeper understanding of the complex issues facing the Catholic Church today.

What are readers saying?

"A People Adrift: The Crisis of the Roman Catholic Church in America" by Peter Steinfels received a mixed response from readers. Steinfels delves into the challenges faced by the Catholic Church in America and offers a critical analysis of its current state.

Many reviewers praised Steinfels for his thorough research and insightful commentary. They appreciated his balanced approach, which helped them understand the complex issues affecting the Catholic Church. Readers found the historical context provided by the author to be valuable in understanding the roots of the crisis. They found the book thought-provoking and appreciated Steinfels' willingness to address sensitive topics within the Church.

However, some readers expressed disappointment with the book. They felt that Steinfels' analysis was biased and lacked objectivity. They believed he did not provide enough solutions or recommendations to address the problems he highlighted. Some found the book too dense and difficult to follow, especially for those without a deep knowledge of Catholicism or the Church's history. A few reviewers also felt that the author focused too heavily on scandal and controversy, neglecting the positive aspects of the Church.

Despite these contrasting opinions, most readers agreed that "A People Adrift" is a valuable resource for understanding the challenges faced by the Roman Catholic Church in America. The book comprehensively examines various factors contributing to the crisis, such as changing demographics, shifts in religious practices, and cultural influences. It encourages readers to reflect on the future of the Church and raises important questions that need to be addressed.

Overall, "A People Adrift" offers a thought-provoking analysis of the crisis in the Roman Catholic Church. While some readers appreciated the author's research and balanced approach, others felt that the book lacked objectivity and solutions. Despite the criticism, the book remains a valuable resource for those seeking a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by the Church in America.

APeopleAdrift BookRecommendation MustRead