A Respectable Trade : Book Review

"A Respectable Trade" by Philippa Gregory takes readers on a journey back to 18th-century Bristol, England, during the peak of the slave trade. This historical fiction novel revolves around two central characters, Frances Scott and Josiah Cole, who find themselves in a marriage of convenience with the goal of personal gain. Frances, a wealthy young widow, is captivated by the immense profit potential of the slave trade and forms a partnership with the ambitious and unscrupulous Josiah. As their lives intertwine, they become embroiled in a web of secrets, betrayals, and moral dilemmas.

The novel delves into themes of power, corruption, and the devastating consequences of the slave trade. Gregory skillfully portrays the intricacies of the era and presents a cast of vibrant and well-rounded characters. Frances, in particular, experiences a transformation as she becomes more deeply involved in the slave trade, continually grappling with the conflicting emotions of wealth and the ethical implications of her actions. In contrast, Josiah is a compelling character driven by his insatiable desire for success and recognition.

Gregory's evocative and engaging writing style transports readers to the bustling streets of Bristol and the horrific conditions aboard slave ships. She does not shy away from depicting the brutal realities of the slave trade, shedding light on the inhumanity and dehumanization that occurred. The author's meticulous research is evident throughout the novel, providing a deeper sense of authenticity to the historical backdrop.

Moreover, "A Respectable Trade" serves as a poignant reminder that the legacy of slavery still impacts society today. The novel underscores the complicity and moral compromises made by individuals seeking personal gain from the suffering of others. It is a thought-provoking and haunting exploration of a dark chapter in history.

Overall, Philippa Gregory's "A Respectable Trade" is a captivating and thought-provoking novel that masterfully combines historical accuracy with compelling storytelling. It delves into the intricate moral complexities of the slave trade through the perspectives of complex and compelling characters, offering readers a profound understanding of the human toll of such exploitation.

What are readers saying?

Philippa Gregory's novel "A Respectable Trade" has received a diverse range of reviews. Set in 18th-century England, the book delves into the historical background of the slave trade and its impact on individuals' lives.

Some readers appreciated the book's historical accuracy and attention to detail. They praised Gregory's meticulous research, which effectively transported them back in time. The vivid descriptions of the setting and characters were highly regarded for their ability to bring the story to life. These readers commended Gregory's engaging writing style and found the narrative to be thought-provoking.

However, there were others who expressed disappointment with the novel. They felt that the pacing was slow and that the plot lacked excitement. Several reviewers struggled to connect with the characters, finding them one-dimensional and lacking depth. Some believed that the book focused too heavily on historical context, at the expense of fully developing the characters and their relationships.

The exploration of themes surrounding slavery and its impact on society was consistently considered thought-provoking. Readers appreciated Gregory's ability to tackle such a difficult subject matter and shed light on the human cost of the slave trade. However, some reviewers felt that the portrayal of slavery was not as emotionally impactful as they had hoped, and that the novel missed an opportunity to delve deeper into the moral complexities of the time.

Overall, Philippa Gregory's "A Respectable Trade" has received a range of reviews. While some readers praised the historical accuracy, engaging writing style, and thought-provoking themes, others found the pacing slow and the characters lacking depth. The novel is highly recommended to those who enjoy historical fiction and have an interest in exploring the historical context of the slave trade in 18th-century England. However, readers seeking a faster-paced, more character-driven story may find this book less satisfying.

RespectableTrade HistoricalFiction SlaveTrade