A View of the State of Ireland : Book Review

"A View of the State of Ireland" by Edmund Spenser is an insightful analysis of the political and social landscape of Ireland during the late 16th century. Spenser, a renowned poet and English colonial administrator, offers a comprehensive account of the issues that plagued Ireland during this time, including the complicated relationship between the English and Irish, the impact of religious divisions, and the challenges of governing the island.

While Spenser's bias towards the English perspective is evident throughout the book, his analysis remains valuable in providing insight into the prevailing attitudes and beliefs of the era. He portrays the Irish as inferior and uncivilized, but his words shed light on the mindset of the English colonizers. Spenser advocates for a more forceful approach to governing Ireland, proposing harsh measures to suppress dissent and asserting English dominance over Irish culture and society.

In addition to politics, Spenser delves into the religious divisions within Ireland, specifically addressing the tensions between Protestantism and Catholicism. He argues for the suppression of Catholicism and the promotion of Protestantism as a means of bringing stability and unity to the country. Although controversial by today's standards, his views offer valuable insights into the religious conflicts of the time.

Despite his biases, Spenser's work presents a comprehensive examination of the state of Ireland in the late 16th century. His detailed analysis of the challenges faced by the English authorities in governing the island, as well as the complex dynamics between the English and Irish populations, make this book an essential resource for scholars and historians interested in Irish history.

In conclusion, "A View of the State of Ireland" remains an important historical document that highlights the political, social, and religious complexities of 16th-century Ireland. While one should be mindful of the author's biases, the book provides valuable insights into the prevailing attitudes and beliefs during this pivotal period.

What are readers saying?

"A View of the State of Ireland" written by Edmund Spenser offers valuable insights into the condition of Ireland in the late 16th century. Reviews for this book present a diverse range of perspectives, highlighting both positive and negative aspects.

Some reviewers appreciate Spenser's deep understanding of Irish history and his detailed analysis of the social and political situation in Ireland at the time. They admire his eloquent writing style and how he presents his arguments with clarity and conviction. These reviewers consider the book an important historical source that sheds light on the complexities of Irish history.

However, some reviewers express concerns about the book's biased portrayal of Ireland and its people. They argue that Spenser's English background heavily influences his perspective, and he often disregards the Irish viewpoint. These reviewers believe that Spenser's assessments are based on stereotypes rather than thorough research, contributing to a negative portrayal of Ireland.

Furthermore, some reviewers criticize Spenser's proposals for English colonization of Ireland, deeming them unjust and oppressive. They argue that his suggestions for suppressing Irish culture and language are ethically wrong and impractical.

On the other hand, there are reviewers who recognize the historical value of Spenser's work while acknowledging its limitations. They emphasize the importance of considering other sources and viewpoints to gain a more comprehensive understanding of Irish history.

IrishHistory StateOfIreland BookRecommendation