"After Admission" by James E. Rosenbaum is a thought-provoking and enlightening book that challenges traditional beliefs about college admission and its impact on a student's success. Rosenbaum argues that gaining admission to college is just the beginning of a student's educational journey, rather than the ultimate goal. Through extensive research and real-life case studies, the author explores alternative pathways and offers valuable insights into how students can thrive in college and beyond.
The book sheds light on the issue of "undermatching," which refers to high-achieving students from disadvantaged backgrounds who fail to attend colleges that match their abilities. Rosenbaum emphasizes that simply gaining admission to any college does not guarantee success; students need a supportive environment that fosters both their academic and personal growth. He advocates for colleges to go beyond admitting students and pushing them towards a generic curriculum. Instead, personalized strategies and support systems are needed to address each student's unique needs.
A key argument in the book is that students' experiences during college, such as engagement in extracurricular activities, internships, and mentorship opportunities, play a crucial role in their future success. Rosenbaum highlights the importance of these experiences in shaping students' career prospects and overall well-being. He challenges the notion that attending an elite college automatically guarantees a successful future, stating that the fit between a student and their chosen college matters more than the institution's prestige.
Available on Audible
Additionally, the author explores the potential of community colleges and vocational training programs as viable alternatives to traditional four-year colleges. By showcasing success stories from these non-traditional pathways, Rosenbaum challenges the prevailing belief that a bachelor's degree is the only path to success in today's job market. He advocates for a more inclusive and flexible approach to education that considers diverse student needs and aspirations.
In conclusion, "After Admission" offers valuable insights into the flaws of the current college admissions system and provides alternative perspectives on ensuring student success. James E. Rosenbaum challenges conventional thinking and presents a compelling case for reevaluating our educational priorities. This book is highly recommended for educators, policymakers, and students who want to better understand the complexities of the college admissions process and its implications for students' futures.
What are readers saying?
James E. Rosenbaum's book "After Admission" has garnered a range of reviews that highlight its insightful and thought-provoking content. Readers have praised the book for its comprehensive exploration of the challenges students face after gaining admission to college.
Many reviewers commend Rosenbaum's in-depth research and analysis, appreciating the book's ability to provide a comprehensive understanding of the struggles students often encounter post-admission. They also express gratitude for the practical advice and strategies offered in the book, which they believe can truly benefit students navigating this phase.
Readers find Rosenbaum's writing style and presentation to be engaging and well-structured. They appreciate the use of real-life stories and examples, which make the information more relatable. Many also find the author's tone approachable, avoiding technical jargon or academic language.
Another aspect of the book that several reviewers value is its focus on socioeconomic disparities and how they impact students' experiences after college admission. Rosenbaum's examination of the challenges faced by low-income and first-generation college students, as well as the role of race and ethnicity, is considered eye-opening and an important addition to the discussion.
While some reviewers express a desire for more specific strategies and actionable steps, they still find value in the book's overall message. They appreciate the theoretical insights provided but would have liked more concrete advice on overcoming obstacles. Despite this minor criticism, they believe the book's direction is valuable.
AfterAdmission BookReading LiteraryJourney