Against Interpretation and Other Essays : Book Review

"Against Interpretation and Other Essays" by Susan Sontag is a captivating collection of essays that boldly challenges the prevailing methods of interpreting art and literature. Sontag argues against the excessive focus on interpretation and instead advocates for a more immersive and sensory approach to experiencing works of art. Throughout the book, she explores various themes, including the significance of style, the concept of camp, the role of critics, and the limitations of interpreting photography.

One of the central arguments presented in this book is the need to move away from interpretation and towards a deeper appreciation of art's inherent qualities. Sontag critiques the tendency to reduce artworks to their intended meanings, urging readers to engage with art on a more immediate and visceral level. According to her, interpretation often restricts the full experience and potential of art, emphasizing instead the importance of embracing aesthetic pleasure and the element of arbitrariness.

Camp is another crucial theme that Sontag examines in her essays. She thoroughly explores the concept of camp as an aesthetic sensibility that celebrates artifice, exaggeration, and irony. Through her insightful analysis, Sontag underscores the subversive power of camp and its ability to challenge societal norms and expectations.

In addition, Sontag delves into the role of critics and questions their authority. She challenges the idea that critics should impose their own interpretations onto artworks and instead advocates for a more open and dialogical approach. Sontag believes that critics should embrace diverse perspectives and encourage a meaningful conversation rather than imposing their opinions as absolute truths.

Furthermore, Sontag tackles the interpretation and significance of photography. She challenges the notion that photographs capture objective truth and argues that they can be subject to multiple interpretations. Sontag emphasizes the need to critically examine photographs and consider the ways in which they can be manipulated.

What are readers saying?

The collection of essays titled "Against Interpretation and Other Essays" by Susan Sontag has garnered a range of reviews. Opinions on the book have been divided, with some readers appreciating the depth and intelligence of Sontag's essays, while others finding them pretentious and difficult to comprehend.

Many positive reviews commend Sontag's intellectual rigor and her ability to provoke new ways of thinking. Readers particularly value her insights on art, literature, and culture. They admire her elegant prose and her skill in addressing complex subjects with clarity. Her examination of the role of interpretation in art and society is seen as thought-provoking and enlightening.

However, negative reviews criticize Sontag's writing style as dense and inaccessible. Some readers struggle with her abstract ideas, finding them difficult to grasp. Critics argue that her essays lack coherence and are overly focused on theory, rather than offering practical application. Additionally, they contend that Sontag's elitist tone makes her work less relatable, excluding readers who are not well-versed in the topics she discusses.

Furthermore, a few readers express disappointment with the dated nature of some essays in the book. They feel that Sontag's ideas were more relevant during the book's original publication in the 1960s and 1970s, losing some impact in the present day. Some readers also find the book repetitive, as certain themes and ideas are reiterated throughout the different essays.

Overall, opinions on "Against Interpretation and Other Essays" present a mix of appreciation for Sontag's intellectual prowess and criticism of her writing style and accessibility. While some readers find her essays insightful and thought-provoking, others argue that her work is too abstract and difficult to understand. Ultimately, the reception of the book appears to depend on the reader's personal preferences and familiarity with the subjects discussed.

AgainstInterpretation EssaysBySusanSontag LiteraryCriticism