Aliens in America: The Strange Truth about Our Souls : Book Review

"Aliens in America" by Peter Augustine Lawler delves into the impact of modernity on American society and the struggles it presents to traditional values and beliefs. The book explores how rapid changes brought about by technology, consumerism, and individualism have made many Americans feel like strangers in their own country. Lawler examines diverse aspects of American life, including politics, education, religion, and popular culture, in order to shed light on the alienation experienced by many individuals today.

Lawler begins by discussing the decline of American exceptionalism and the erosion of national identity in the face of globalization. He argues that America's pursuit of individual freedom and material wealth has resulted in a loss of community and meaningful relationships. To combat this alienation, Lawler suggests embracing our unique cultural heritage and seeking a sense of rootedness.

The author also critically examines the impact of technology on American society. While acknowledging the convenience and progress brought about by technological advancements, Lawler highlights the negative consequences, such as a loss of privacy, a decline in authentic human interaction, and an increasing dependency on virtual experiences. He urges readers to reflect on these consequences and find ways to maintain genuine connections in an increasingly digital world.

Education is another area of concern for Lawler. He argues that the modern education system, with its focus on career preparation and specialization, fails to cultivate the virtues and values necessary for well-rounded individuals. Lawler advocates for a return to a more holistic approach to education that emphasizes character formation and the pursuit of wisdom.

Religion and popular culture also come under Lawler's scrutiny. He argues that religion, once a fundamental aspect of American life, has been marginalized and reduced to a purely private matter. Lawler critiques the influence of popular culture on shaping American values and calls for a revival of religious and moral discourse in the public sphere.

What are readers saying?

The book "Aliens in America" by Peter Augustine Lawler has received a mix of reviews. While some readers commend Lawler for his unique perspective and thought-provoking analysis, others find the book dense and difficult to grasp.

Many reviewers appreciate Lawler's ability to offer fresh insights into American culture and politics. They praise his examination of the alienation and rootlessness prevalent in contemporary society, and how these factors impact individuals' sense of identity and belonging. Lawler's knowledge of philosophy and literature is also commended, as he draws on these disciplines to shed light on his arguments.

However, some readers find Lawler's writing style overly academic and inaccessible. They criticize his heavy use of jargon and abstract concepts, considering it a challenge for those without a strong background in philosophy or political theory to follow. In addition, there are frustrations expressed about Lawler's tendency to make sweeping generalizations without providing sufficient evidence or logical reasoning.

Another point of disagreement among reviewers is Lawler's political leanings. While some appreciate his conservative perspective as refreshing, others feel that his political bias becomes too prominent and detracts from the objectivity of his analysis. They argue that his arguments may only resonate with those who share his ideological views.

Despite these criticisms, there is a consensus among reviewers that "Aliens in America" provides valuable insights into the complex nature of American society. Many readers appreciate Lawler's ability to challenge conventional wisdom and provoke thought, even if they do not always agree with his conclusions. Overall, the book is seen as a stimulating and intellectually engaging read, albeit one that may require some effort to fully comprehend.

AliensInAmerica SciFiReads Bookworms