"Among the Thugs" by Bill Buford is an incredibly compelling and eye-opening book that allows readers to immerse themselves in the disturbing world of football hooliganism during the 1980s. Buford, an American journalist living in Britain, takes us on a journey into the depths of this violent subculture, providing firsthand accounts of the raw emotions, mob mentality, and extreme violence that characterize these hooligans.
Buford's writing is vivid and immersive, enabling us to truly understand the intense atmosphere and psychological dynamics within these hooligan groups. Through his personal encounters with these thugs, he offers a unique and authentic perspective on their motivations, tactics, and the strong sense of camaraderie that unites them. By combining interviews, observations, and historical context, Buford paints a comprehensive picture of this deeply disturbing phenomenon.
One of the most captivating aspects of the book is Buford's exploration of his own moral boundaries and the gradual erosion of his initial revulsion towards the violence he witnesses. He exposes the seductive nature of mob mentality and highlights the dangerous allure these hooligans possess. Buford's introspection adds depth to the narrative, transforming it into more than just a documentation of events, but rather a personal journey of self-discovery.
Available on Audible
While "Among the Thugs" is undeniably a disturbing and unsettling read, it is also an incredibly important one. Buford does not glorify or romanticize the hooligan culture, but rather presents it with stark honesty and a critical lens. The book raises poignant questions about society, violence, and the complexities of human behavior when swept up in collective identities. Buford's ability to provoke thought and elicit strong emotional reactions in readers is a testament to his exceptional storytelling skills.
Overall, "Among the Thugs" is a powerful and thought-provoking account of a dark and violent world. Buford's exploration of football hooliganism provides an incisive examination of human behavior and the extreme lengths people can go to when caught up in fervent collective mindsets. It is a book that challenges preconceptions and leaves a lasting impact on readers.
What are readers saying?
Among the Thugs by Bill Buford is a chilling and insightful exploration of football hooliganism in the United Kingdom during the 1980s. The book's reception has been mixed, with some readers praising Buford's immersive and captivating storytelling, while others criticize his depiction of the subject matter.
Buford receives commendation from many reviewers for his fearless and immersive approach to documenting the world of football hooliganism. His personal experiences and interactions with the thugs offer a raw and unfiltered perspective, allowing readers to truly grasp the violence and chaos surrounding football matches. Readers appreciate the intricate and detailed portrayal of the culture, highlighting Buford's dedication to capturing the essence of the hooligan experience.
However, some reviewers express concerns about Buford's writing style and his portrayal of the subject. Some find the narrative to be disjointed and lacking focus, failing to provide a clear analysis or explanation of the issues at hand. Additionally, there are criticisms regarding Buford's tendency to romanticize violence and the hooligan lifestyle, which may be off-putting to some readers.
Despite these concerns, the majority of reviewers applaud Buford for shedding light on a dark and often overlooked aspect of society. Readers admire his courage in immersing himself in the dangerous world of football hooliganism and his ability to share his experiences in an engaging and compelling manner. Many describe the book as gripping and eye-opening, providing a unique insight into a subculture that is shrouded in secrecy.
Overall, Among the Thugs receives a mix of positive and critical reviews. While Buford's immersive storytelling and willingness to explore a controversial subject are applauded, there are reservations about the writing style and potentially glamorizing the violence. Ultimately, the book offers a thought-provoking examination of football hooliganism, providing readers with a greater understanding of the complexities and dangers inherent in this subculture.
AmongTheThugs FootballHooligans HooliganCulture