An Instance Of The Fingerpost : Book Review

"An Instance of the Fingerpost" by Iain Pears is a captivating historical mystery set in 17th century Oxford, England. With its richly woven tapestry of deception, politics, and betrayal, the novel follows the perspectives of four different narrators as they navigate a web of lies and secrets surrounding a shocking murder that threatens to upend the academic community.

The story begins with Marco da Cola, a Venetian medical student, who introduces the murder and sets the stage for the complex tale. Soon, we are introduced to Jack Prestcott, a mysterious figure with a shadowy past, whose unique viewpoint sheds light on the events. Dr. John Wallis, a mathematician and cryptographer, then brings his expertise to the investigation. And finally, Anthony Wood, a historian, meticulously unravels the events, piecing together the truth.

Throughout the novel, it becomes evident that nothing is as it seems. Each narrator harbors their own motivations, biases, and hidden truths, creating a sense of uncertainty and confusion. As the plot unfolds, we are drawn into a world of political intrigue, religious tension, and personal rivalries that heighten the suspense and keep us guessing until the very end.

One of the novel's strengths lies in its historical backdrop. Pears beautifully captures the intellectual and scientific climate of 17th century Oxford, incorporating real historical figures and events. The meticulous attention to detail brings the setting to life, immersing us in a world filled with the intricacies of the time.

"An Instance of the Fingerpost" is a thought-provoking and immersive read that combines elements of historical fiction, mystery, and psychological thriller. Pears' craftsmanship shines through his skillful storytelling and the development of complex characters. As we delve deeper into the story, the novel challenges our beliefs about truth and perception, leaving us questioning our own biases and assumptions.

What are readers saying?

Iain Pears' novel, An Instance of the Fingerpost, has received a range of reviews from readers. Set in 17th century England, the historical mystery follows multiple narrators who each present their own version of events surrounding a murder. Opinions on the book were divided, with some readers praising the intricate plotting and rich historical detail, while others found it excessively long and slow-paced.

Many reviewers appreciated Pears' extensive research and attention to historical accuracy. They commended his vivid descriptions of 17th century Oxford, which transported them back in time. The complex and multilayered plot received applause, with several readers enjoying the suspense and the narrative unfolding through different perspectives.

However, there were readers who struggled with the book. Some felt that the pacing was slow and the story unnecessarily dragged on. Several reviewers found the multiple narrators and shifting perspectives challenging to follow, making it difficult to keep track of the plot and the characters.

Opinions on the characters varied as well. Some readers found them well-developed and believable, praising Pears' ability to capture human nature's complexities. Conversely, a few reviewers felt that the characters lacked depth and connection, resulting in a lack of emotional investment in their stories.

Regarding the writing style, several readers praised Pears' elegant prose and descriptive language, appreciating the intricate level of detail. However, there were others who found the writing dense and overly verbose, making it harder for them to stay engaged with the narrative.

HistoricalMystery IntriguingPlot MultiplePerspectives