"Ancients against Moderns" by Joan DeJean delves into the clash between the cultural ideals of Ancient and Modern societies in 17th and 18th century France. DeJean argues that this clash had a profound impact on the development of French literature, art, and intellectual thought during this period.
DeJean provides historical context, exploring how the cultural resurgence of classical antiquity in the 17th century challenged the prevailing values of the Enlightenment. She highlights the tensions between those who championed the ideals of the ancient world, which emphasized tradition and order, and those who embraced progress, reason, and individualism.
The author focuses on key figures who played significant roles in this debate, including renowned writers like Molière, Racine, and La Fontaine. DeJean demonstrates how their works reflected their own positions in the Ancients against Moderns conflict. In addition, she examines the impact of the debate on artistic movements and intellectual circles of the time.
Available on Audible
One of the strengths of DeJean's book is her ability to present complex ideas and debates in a clear and accessible manner. She strikes a balance between providing detailed historical analysis and engaging storytelling, making the book enjoyable for readers unfamiliar with the subject matter. Her meticulous research and use of primary sources add credibility to her arguments.
In conclusion, "Ancients against Moderns" offers a captivating exploration of the clash between the cultural ideals of Ancient and Modern societies and its influence on French literature, art, and thought in the 17th and 18th centuries. DeJean's expertise and engaging writing style make this book an invaluable resource for anyone interested in this period of French history and its intellectual and artistic movements.
What are readers saying?
"Ancients Against Moderns: Culture Wars and the Making of a Fin de Siecle" by Joan DeJean is a thought-provoking exploration of the cultural conflicts that emerged in Paris during the late 17th and early 18th centuries. DeJean meticulously examines art, literature, architecture, and fashion to shed light on the clash between the advocates of classical culture (the Ancients) and those embracing modernity (the Moderns).
The book has received predominantly positive reviews, praising DeJean's extensive research and her ability to present complex ideas in an accessible manner. Readers appreciate how the book provides a comprehensive understanding of the ongoing debates and tensions in French society, delving deep into the cultural milieu of the time.
One aspect that resonates with readers is DeJean's analysis of the impact of these cultural conflicts on various aspects of society. From the development of the Parisian cityscape to the changing attitudes towards fashion, DeJean connects these cultural battles to their wider consequences, revealing their profound influence on shaping the era.
Moreover, many reviewers commend the author's engaging writing style, making "Ancients Against Moderns" an enjoyable read for both academics and general readers. DeJean's storytelling abilities and her talent for illuminating historical events through lively anecdotes captivate her audience, preventing the book from becoming dry or inaccessible.
While some critics note that the book may not be suitable for readers seeking a purely narrative-driven account, the majority perceive this as a strength. They appreciate the intellectual depth and rigorous analysis offered by DeJean as she delves into the intricacies of cultural debates.
AncientsVsModerns BookRecommendation LiteraryClash