Apologies to the Iroquois : Book Review

"Apologies to the Iroquois" by Edmund Wilson offers a thought-provoking and insightful exploration of Native American history and culture, focusing primarily on the Iroquois Confederacy. Through a series of essays, Wilson delves into various topics, including the impact of European colonization, the role of Native Americans in American literature, and the challenges faced by Indigenous communities. With meticulous research and engaging prose, the author provides a comprehensive examination of these issues, while also acknowledging the historical shortcomings and injustices faced by Native Americans.

Wilson's storytelling skills are evident throughout the book as he effortlessly weaves together historical facts, personal observations, and literary analysis. His writing style is clear, concise, and accessible, making complex subjects easy to understand. Through his engaging narratives, Wilson prompts readers to critically reflect on the history, stereotypes, and misconceptions surrounding Native American culture, offering fresh perspectives and challenging conventional narratives.

Moreover, Wilson emphasizes the significant contributions of Native peoples to American literature. By highlighting the works of Native American writers such as Ohiyesa (Charles Eastman) and Mourning Dove, he showcases the richness and complexity of Native American storytelling traditions and their essential role in shaping the American literary canon.

However, it's important to note that the book was first published in 1960, and some readers may find Wilson's approach and language outdated. Perspectives and understanding of Indigenous peoples have evolved significantly since then, and certain passages may be perceived as offensive or perpetuating stereotypes.

Despite this limitation, "Apologies to the Iroquois" remains a valuable resource for those interested in Native American history and literature. It prompts readers to question dominant narratives, recognize the lasting effects of colonization, and acknowledge the remarkable contributions of Native Americans to American culture. By delving into these complex issues, Wilson's work encourages readers to critically engage with the past and present, fostering a more inclusive and comprehensive understanding of Native American experiences.

What are readers saying?

The reception of Edmund Wilson's book "Apologies to the Iroquois" has been diverse among readers. The work delves into the history and treatment of Native Americans by European settlers, providing a critical examination of their actions. While some reviewers appreciate Wilson's historical analysis and thought-provoking ideas, others criticize the book for its outdated perspectives and insensitivity.

One reviewer commends Wilson for his extensive research and thorough examination of the subject matter. They appreciate his ability to challenge common misconceptions and shed light on the injustices faced by Native American tribes. The reviewer considers the book a valuable resource for understanding the complex relationship between settlers and indigenous people.

Another reader finds Wilson's book to be insightful and engaging. They appreciate his ability to explain historical events in a clear and accessible manner, making it suitable for a wide range of readers. Additionally, the reviewer highlights the relevance of the book in addressing ongoing racial issues and fostering a greater understanding of Native American history.

However, not all reviewers were impressed with "Apologies to the Iroquois." Some readers criticize Wilson for his lack of sensitivity and empathy towards Native American experiences. They feel that he approached the subject matter with a condescending and colonialist perspective, failing to fully grasp the impact of the settler-colonial relationship on indigenous populations.

Several readers also note that the publication date of 1960 renders some of the book's information and viewpoints outdated. They argue for contextualizing Wilson's work within the historical and sociopolitical climate of its time, considering the advancements and changes in scholarship on Native American history since then.

ApologiesToTheIroquois IndigenousLiterature CulturalAppreciation