Apologies to Thucydides: Understanding History as Culture and Vice Versa : Book Review

"Apologies to Thucydides" by Marshall S. Poe offers readers a fresh and thought-provoking perspective on the study of history. In this book, Poe delves into the complex relationship between historians, their narratives, and the elusive nature of truth. Through a series of engaging essays, he challenges the conventional understanding of history, urging readers to critically examine the biases and motivations that shape historical accounts.

Poe centers his discussion around the ancient Greek historian Thucydides, particularly his renowned work, "History of the Peloponnesian War." He contends that historians, similar to Thucydides, often present their narratives as objective truth while acknowledging the subjectivity that inherently influences their interpretations. This prompts readers to question the persuasive tactics and language employed by historians to construct a particular narrative that aligns with their agenda.

One key aspect of Poe's exploration is the recognition of the limitations inherent in historical knowledge. He emphasizes the challenges historians face in accessing accurate information and the subjective nature of human memory. By doing so, he compellingly argues against the notion of history as an absolute truth and encourages readers to approach it skeptically.

Additionally, Poe highlights the influential role of the audience and the context in shaping historical narratives. Historians write with a specific audience in mind, seeking to persuade and influence their readers. Moreover, the social and cultural context in which historical accounts are received can significantly impact their interpretations. Poe draws attention to the multiplicity of perspectives that emerge as a result, showcasing the complex and ever-evolving nature of history.

In essence, "Apologies to Thucydides" presents a captivating and insightful assessment of the intricacies of historical writing. Poe's exploration of the interplay between historians, their narratives, and the concept of truth encourages readers to engage with history critically. By recognizing the subjectivity and various influences at play, we gain a deeper understanding of the complexities and nuances inherent in the study of history.

What are readers saying?

Apologies to Thucydides by Marshall Sahlins has garnered a wide range of opinions from readers on Goodreads. Many praise the author's depth of knowledge and exceptional writing style, while others argue that the book is too complex and academic.

A recurring theme in positive reviews is the wealth of historical and anthropological knowledge that Sahlins brings to the table. Readers appreciate his thorough exploration of connections between societies throughout history, as well as his ability to draw insightful comparisons. Sahlins' expertise and extensive research are highly regarded by those who appreciate a scholarly approach to history.

However, the book's intellectual nature is a point of contention for some readers. They criticize Sahlins' dense and academic writing style, finding it difficult for the average reader to fully engage with the content. The complex language and heavy use of jargon can be overwhelming and may deter those seeking a more accessible reading experience.

Some reviewers commend Sahlins' unique perspective and his ability to challenge conventional historical narratives. They appreciate how Apologies to Thucydides prompts readers to reevaluate their understanding of history and question existing assumptions. By offering alternative interpretations and raising thought-provoking questions, Sahlins stimulates intellectual debate and encourages critical thinking.

On the other hand, some readers find the book's structure and organization confusing. They note that the narrative jumps between different subjects and time periods without clear transitions, making it challenging to follow the author's arguments cohesively. These readers argue that a more streamlined and straightforward approach would have enhanced the overall reading experience.

ApologiesToThucydides GoodreadsReads HistoricalNonfiction