As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl : Book Review

"As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl" by John Colapinto is a gripping and thought-provoking account of the true story of David Reimer. This book recounts the tragic accident that left David without a penis during a routine circumcision and the controversial experiment that followed.

Renowned psychologist Dr. John Money recommended raising David as a girl in an attempt to determine his most suitable gender. Colapinto skillfully narrates the devastating consequences of this experiment, which ultimately contradicted Dr. Money's claims of gender neutrality. Despite efforts to shape David into a female identity, he struggled with his assigned gender throughout his childhood and adolescence. The author chronicles David's eventual decision to reclaim his male identity, examining the immense emotional and psychological challenges he faced.

This book delves deep into the controversial nature versus nurture debate, raising crucial questions about interpersonal relationships, gender identity, and the limits of medical intervention. Colapinto explores the ethical implications of Dr. Money's experiment and vividly portrays the devastating impact it had on David's life. This thought-provoking exploration challenges traditional views on gender and identity.

Through extensive research and interviews, Colapinto provides a comprehensive and engaging account of David's journey. The author's empathetic and impartial approach allows readers to understand the intense struggle David faced throughout his life. Colapinto also reveals the flaws and biases that plagued Dr. Money's research, exposing the dangerous consequences of his misguided theories.

Overall, "As Nature Made Him" is a powerful and relevant book that exposes the complexities of gender identity and emphasizes the importance of personal autonomy. Colapinto's engaging writing style and meticulous research make this book an informative and compelling read, leaving readers with a profound understanding of the significant impact that gender has on the human experience. It serves as a reminder of the need for empathy and understanding in discussions surrounding gender and identity.

What are readers saying?

As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl is a captivating and thought-provoking book that delves into the controversial topic of gender identity. Written by John Colapinto, this non-fiction work tells the true story of David Reimer, a Canadian boy who was mistakenly raised as a girl named Brenda due to a botched circumcision. The book explores the profound consequences of this decision and sheds light on the immense challenges faced by David as he struggled with his own identity.

The overall reception of As Nature Made Him has been overwhelmingly positive, with readers praising Colapinto for his gripping storytelling and extensive research. The author's ability to handle such a sensitive subject matter with utmost sensitivity and respect has been highly commended, particularly in addressing the ethical dilemmas associated with David's medical treatment. Reviewers also express admiration for the book's comprehensive examination of gender identity and its profound impact on David's life.

Readers particularly value the knowledge and insight gained from reading this book, as it provides a deeper understanding of the intricate complexities of gender. The exploration of nature versus nurture, the significance of identity, and the lasting effects of traumatic experiences make As Nature Made Him an engaging and enlightening read, appealing to those interested in psychology, gender studies, and medical ethics alike.

However, it is worth noting that some reviewers mention the emotionally challenging nature of the book, cautioning potential readers about its sensitive content. They advise approaching the book with caution and recommending it to those who are comfortable exploring such topics. Additionally, a few readers voice their disappointment with the pacing of the narrative, suggesting that it could have been tightened to maintain a more consistent level of engagement throughout.

In conclusion, the product reviews for As Nature Made Him highlight it as a well-researched and thought-provoking book. Its insightful exploration of David Reimer's life and the complex issues of gender identity and medical ethics have struck a chord with many readers. While some caution against the emotionally challenging content, the majority appreciate the book's depth and its ability to shed light on a complex and important topic.

AsNatureMadeHim GenderIdentity TrueStory