"Basic Documents about the Treatment of Detainees at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib" by W. Frederick Zimmerman offers a comprehensive collection of primary source materials shedding light on the treatment of detainees during the War on Terror. This book includes a range of official government documents, testimonies, legal opinions, and reports, providing readers with factual information to form their own opinions on this controversial issue.
Zimmerman's careful compilation of these documents presents them in a chronological order, allowing readers to trace the evolution of events and the underlying policies that influenced detainee treatment. From the early days of detentions at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib to subsequent investigations and reports, readers gain a deep understanding of the various aspects surrounding this topic.
What sets this book apart is its inclusion of documents from multiple perspectives. In addition to government reports, Zimmerman also includes detainee testimonies, international legal opinions, and Red Cross reports. This diverse range of sources offers a well-rounded view of the complex issues at hand, including the challenges faced by detainees, the controversies surrounding interrogation techniques, and the legal and ethical questions raised by these practices.
Available on Audible
To further enhance readers' understanding, Zimmerman provides insightful introductions and commentaries that provide crucial context and analysis for each document. This aids readers in comprehending the significance of these materials and their implications. Importantly, Zimmerman maintains an unbiased approach, allowing readers to form their own conclusions and encouraging critical thinking.
"Basic Documents about the Treatment of Detainees at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib" is an invaluable resource for those seeking a deeper understanding of the detainee treatment controversies. Zimmerman's meticulous compilation of primary source materials, coupled with his insightful commentary, offers a comprehensive exploration of this significant topic, unbiased by personal opinions or biases.
What are readers saying?
W. Frederick Zimmerman's book, "Basic Documents about the Treatment of Detainees at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib," has elicited mixed reviews from readers. This compilation of various documents sheds light on the treatment of detainees at these controversial detention centers, but opinions on the book vary.
Some readers laud the book for its comprehensive collection of primary source documents, which they appreciate for providing unedited and unbiased information. These readers find value in being able to form their own opinions, as the author presents the documents without interjecting analysis or commentary. They believe that this book acts as a valuable resource in understanding the complexities and controversies surrounding these detention centers.
On the other hand, some readers express disappointment in the lack of analysis or commentary in the book. They argue that the author missed an opportunity to provide context and a deeper understanding of the issues at hand. These readers find the collection of documents to be confusing and disjointed without the author's guidance.
Criticism is also directed towards the organization and presentation of the book. Some readers find the layout to be confusing and disorganized, making it difficult to navigate through the extensive collection of documents. These readers suggest that better editing and structuring would improve the book's readability.
Furthermore, a few readers criticize Zimmerman for what they perceive as a bias in favor of the detainees. They argue that the author fails to provide a balanced perspective or include documents that present alternative points of view. These readers believe that a more objective approach would have enhanced the book's credibility and informativeness.
DetaineeTreatment GuantanamoAbuGhraib HumanRights