Before the Closet: Same-Sex Love from "Beowulf" to "Angels in America" : Book Review

In "Before the Closet" by Allen J. Frantzen, the intriguing history of same-sex desire in medieval Europe is thoroughly explored, offering a fresh perspective on this often misunderstood topic. Frantzen's analysis delves into original sources and challenges traditional assumptions, asserting that same-sex desire was more openly acknowledged and accepted than previously believed.

The book's strength lies in Frantzen's meticulous examination of primary sources, such as medieval literature, letters, and legal texts. By skillfully uncovering instances of homoerotic language and relationships, he sheds light on the presence of same-sex desire within medieval society. This comprehensive research and analysis provide valuable insights into the complex attitudes towards homosexuality during this time.

Frantzen effectively presents his arguments in an accessible and engaging writing style that appeals to both scholars and general readers. He presents his ideas clearly and supports them with strong evidence, guiding readers through the intricate nuances of medieval society and its understanding of same-sex desire.

Additionally, "Before the Closet" challenges the widely held assumption that heterosexual identity was absent in the Middle Ages. Frantzen argues convincingly that individuals in medieval Europe possessed complex sexual identities, and that same-sex desire did not necessarily indicate an absence of heterosexual desire or identification.

Overall, "Before the Closet" is a compelling and significant book that adds nuance and depth to our understanding of same-sex desire in medieval Europe. Frantzen's extensive research and analysis, combined with his accessible writing style, make this book an invaluable resource for anyone interested in the history of sexuality.

What are readers saying?

Before the Closet by Allen J. Frantzen is highly regarded for its scholarly examination of homosexuality in medieval literature. Readers appreciate Frantzen's meticulous research and thoughtful approach to the subject matter. The book sheds light on the intricate and multifaceted nature of sexuality during the Middle Ages, offering valuable insights that are still relevant to contemporary discussions.

Frantzen's extensive exploration of medieval texts is praised for providing a comprehensive understanding of the historical context surrounding the perception and acceptance of homosexuality. The author challenges common misconceptions and offers nuanced interpretations, enriching our understanding of the topic. The inclusion of lesser-known texts further broadens the scope of analysis and deepens our understanding of the complexities involved.

What distinguishes Before the Closet is the author's ability to make complex topics accessible to a wide range of readers. Frantzen's clear and engaging writing style appeals to both academic and general audiences, making the book suitable for teaching purposes as well. The book's potential to spark further research is also highlighted, as it encourages readers to delve deeper into the subject matter.

One of the book's key achievements is its role in dispelling stereotypes about the Middle Ages. Frantzen captures the diverse experiences of individuals with non-heterosexual orientations during that time period, challenging preconceived notions and offering a more nuanced perspective. This aspect of Before the Closet is highly praised, as it contributes to a better understanding of the historical complexities of sexuality.

Overall, the reviews affirm the high quality of Allen J. Frantzen's Before the Closet, acknowledging the author's meticulous research, clear writing style, and insightful analysis. The book serves as a valuable resource for academic study and offers a comprehensive understanding of the complexity of sexuality during the Middle Ages. By challenging common misconceptions and providing nuanced interpretations, Frantzen's work deepens our understanding and appreciation of this historical topic.

BeforetheCloset HiddenTruths LGBTQReads