Beggars and Choosers : Book Review

Catrin Collier's "Beggars and Choosers" is a captivating and immersive novel that transports readers to the gritty streets of 1930s Cardiff. Set against a backdrop of poverty and social unrest, the story follows the lives of two women, Rose and Meg, as they navigate the challenges and hardships that come with their circumstances.

The strength of this novel lies in its well-developed characters and vivid prose. Collier skillfully portrays the struggles and vulnerabilities of Rose and Meg, allowing readers to empathize with their experiences. Rose, with her determination to escape her impoverished background, and Meg, with her graceful and cautious approach to life, offer contrasting perspectives and add depth to the narrative.

One of the standout aspects of "Beggars and Choosers" is its attention to historical detail. Collier brings 1930s Cardiff to life, painting a vivid picture of the city's stark contrasts between the grimy streets of the working class and the opulence of the upper class. This authenticity adds richness to the story, transporting readers to a bygone era and immersing them in the social and political turmoil of the time.

The novel also touches upon important themes such as social inequality and the impact of the Great Depression. Through Rose and Meg's experiences, Collier explores the stark divide between the wealthy and the destitute, shedding light on the struggles faced by those on the margins of society. This exploration serves as a powerful reminder of the lasting consequences of economic disparity.

Overall, "Beggars and Choosers" is a thought-provoking and compelling read that combines strong characters, a vivid historical setting, and important societal themes. Collier's skillful storytelling transports readers to another time, allowing them to fully engage with the struggles and triumphs of these resilient women. Fans of historical fiction will be captivated by this engrossing and well-crafted narrative.

What are readers saying?

"Beggars and Choosers" by Catrin Collier has received a range of reviews from readers, reflecting different perspectives on the novel. The story is set in Wales during World War II, focusing on a family's struggles with poverty, love, and the profound impact of the war on their lives.

Some readers praised Collier's talent for capturing the atmosphere and historical backdrop of the time period. They appreciated her meticulous research, which added authenticity to the narrative. Collier's descriptive writing style and vivid portrayals of the characters were also commended, as they allowed readers to connect with and empathize with the protagonists.

However, other readers found the book to be slow-paced and lacking in plot development. They felt that the story was predictable, without any surprising or exciting twists. Some reviewers also noted that the characters were one-dimensional and lacked depth, making it difficult for them to fully engage with the story and relate to the protagonists.

Regardless of the mixed feedback, many readers admired Collier's exploration of important themes such as poverty, war, and familial relationships. The novel's examination of how these circumstances affected the characters emotionally and psychologically was seen as a particular strength.

On the other hand, some readers felt that the book could have benefited from stronger editing, as they encountered instances of grammatical errors and inconsistencies. Some reviewers also mentioned that the pacing of the book was uneven, with certain parts dragging on while others felt rushed.

BeggarsAndChoosers BookLovers MustReads