Being-In-The-World: A Commentary on Heidegger's Being in Time, Division I : Book Review

"Being-in-the-World" by Hubert L. Dreyfus offers a stimulating exploration of our existence and the way we interact with the world. Dreyfus challenges the prevailing belief that our minds are separate from our bodies, instead proposing that our minds are deeply entwined with our physical being and our interactions with the physical and social environment. Through drawing on the teachings of philosophers like Heidegger and Merleau-Ponty, Dreyfus presents a persuasive argument for the significance of our lived experience and active engagement in comprehending our existence.

One of the prominent themes in the book is the idea that our skills and expertise are not solely products of our minds, but are fundamentally linked to our bodily interactions with the world. Dreyfus employs examples ranging from top athletes to renowned musicians to demonstrate how our embodiment enables us to develop a profound understanding and intuitive mastery of complex activities. He contends that our tacit understanding of the world cannot be reduced to explicit rules or conscious knowledge, but rather emerges from our lived experiences and continuous engagements with our surroundings.

Dreyfus also delves into the concept of authenticity, highlighting the importance of being true to oneself and embracing our individuality in a world that often imposes societal norms and expectations. He suggests that by engaging in meaningful and purposeful activities, we can discover a sense of fulfillment and belonging. This perspective challenges the notion that happiness can be attained through mere consumption or external validation, instead encouraging us to foster a meaningful relationship with the world around us.

Throughout the book, Dreyfus presents philosophical ideas in a clear and accessible manner, making it suitable for both academic and general readers. He substantiates his arguments with a wide range of examples, incorporating insights from disciplines like psychology, anthropology, and sociology. By prompting us to critically examine our assumptions about the nature of our existence and our relationship with the world, Dreyfus offers a thought-provoking perspective on what it truly means to be in the world.

Hubert L. Dreyfus' book "Being-in-the-World: A Commentary on Heidegger's 'Being and Time'" has received a mixed response from readers. With an average rating of 3.75 stars out of 5, the reviews present both positive and negative aspects of the book.

Many reviewers laud Dreyfus for his profound analysis of Martin Heidegger's "Being and Time." They appreciate how he brings clarity and accessibility to this complex philosophical work, making it more comprehensible for readers. The book is commended for providing valuable insights into Heidegger's philosophy, particularly regarding the concept of being-in-the-world.

Readers also admire Dreyfus' skill in relating Heidegger's ideas to various aspects of everyday life. They find the book highly relevant in interpreting our existence and gaining a deeper understanding of human behavior and experiences. Many reviewers specifically mention the book's thought-provoking explanations and examples.

However, some readers feel that the book could have been better organized. They point out the repetitive nature of the content and a lack of clear structure. This, at times, makes it challenging to follow and impedes full comprehension of the concepts presented.

Another point of criticism is the heavy reliance on Heidegger's original text. While some readers appreciate the thorough approach, others find the frequent citations and references overwhelming, disrupting the flow of the book.

BeingInTheWorld BookLovers ExistentialReading