Beyond Good Intentions: A Mother Reflects on Raising Internationally Adopted Children : Book Review

"Beyond Good Intentions" by Cheri Register is a captivating and profound exploration of the multifaceted aspects of adoption. Drawing from her own experiences as an adoptive mother and extensive research, Register dissects commonly-held beliefs about adoption and delves into the emotional and psychological impacts that adoption has on both the child and the adoptive parents.

One of the standout features of this book is Register's ability to shine a light on the often overlooked challenges faced by adoptive parents. She challenges the prevailing notion that adoption is solely a benevolent and unproblematic act, shedding light on the complexities, uncertainties, and potential pitfalls that can arise during the adoption process and beyond. By sharing personal anecdotes and incorporating research, Register offers a more nuanced perspective on the emotional hurdles that adoptive parents may encounter.

Furthermore, "Beyond Good Intentions" uncovers the often-ignored experiences and emotions of the adopted child. Register explores the intricate interplay between identity, race, and culture, and emphasizes the profound impact these factors can have on an adopted child's sense of self. Through personal stories and academic insights, the book provides a comprehensive examination of the unique challenges faced by adoptees.

The importance of open and honest communication within adoptive families is another focal point of the book. Register underscores the significance of acknowledging and discussing the child's adoption story, as well as the potential consequences of secrecy or incomplete information. She encourages adoptive parents to create a nurturing and open environment where the child feels safe expressing their thoughts and emotions regarding their adoption.

In conclusion, "Beyond Good Intentions" is a thought-provoking and informative book that challenges conventional ideas surrounding adoption. With her own experiences and a wealth of research, Cheri Register offers a valuable resource for anyone seeking to understand the intricate and multifaceted dynamics of adoption. The book's exploration of the complexities faced by adoptive parents and the impact on the adopted child's identity and sense of self make it an indispensable read on the subject.

What are readers saying?

"Beyond Good Intentions" by Cheri Register has generated a mix of opinions from readers. Some found the book thought-provoking and well-written, while others felt it fell short in certain respects.

Many reviewers praised the book for its insightful exploration of the complexities between cross-cultural adoption and identity. They appreciated Cheri Register's empathetic approach and felt that she delved into the subject matter with sensitivity and nuance. Readers found the personal stories and interviews within the book particularly moving and enlightening.

Register also received commendation for her thorough research and diverse inclusion of perspectives. She effectively shed light on the challenges faced by adoptees and adoptive parents, as well as the social, cultural, and racial issues that arise in these situations. The book was regarded as a valuable resource for those involved in cross-cultural adoption, offering emotional support and practical advice.

However, some readers expressed their dissent regarding "Beyond Good Intentions." They felt that while the book covered important topics, it lacked a cohesive structure and failed to fully explore certain aspects of the subject matter. The narrative was seen as somewhat disjointed, and there was a desire for a more organized and focused approach.

Additionally, a small number of reviewers were disappointed with the level of analysis and scholarly rigor in the book. They felt that Register relied too heavily on personal anecdotes and lacked a deeper theoretical framework for understanding the complexities of cross-cultural adoption.

BeyondGoodIntentions BooksToRead SelfGrowth