Black into White: Race and Nationality in Brazilian Thought : Book Review

"Black into White" by Thomas E. Skidmore provides a detailed examination of the complex racial dynamics in Brazil from the 19th century onwards. The book dives into the history of racial blending and social mobility in the country, shedding light on the challenges faced by individuals of African descent in a society that idealized whiteness. Skidmore's extensive research and well-crafted arguments support his thesis, offering a comprehensive analysis of the factors that contributed to the shifting racial landscape in Brazil.

Skidmore explores the historical context of slavery in Brazil and its impact on race relations and racial identity. He also highlights the role of immigration in shaping Brazil's racial hierarchy, emphasizing the influence of European immigrants. The author acknowledges the complexities of racial categorization, recognizing that individuals could pass as white to gain social advantages.

One of the strengths of "Black into White" is Skidmore's incorporation of personal narratives alongside historical analysis. By giving voice to the experiences of individual Afro-Brazilians, he humanizes the historical forces at play, allowing readers to connect emotionally to the struggles, aspirations, and achievements of Afro-Brazilians during this transformative period.

Skidmore also explores how racial ideology shaped the Brazilian national identity. He discusses how ideas of race and color influenced political discourse, public policies, and social aspirations. From the abolition of slavery to the enactment of racial equality laws, Skidmore provides a detailed account of the progress and setbacks experienced by Afro-Brazilians.

In conclusion, "Black into White" is a meticulously researched and thought-provoking book that offers valuable insights into Brazil's complex racial dynamics. Skidmore's in-depth analysis, coupled with engaging personal narratives, makes this book a compelling read for anyone interested in understanding the intersections of race, identity, and social mobility in Brazilian history.

What are readers saying?

"Black into White" by Thomas E. Skidmore has garnered mixed reviews from readers. Some praise the book for its comprehensive examination of racial dynamics in Brazil. They commend Skidmore for his diligent research and the historical context he provides, finding the book both educational and enlightening. These readers appreciate the author's attention to detail and his ability to engage them with his writing.

However, there are readers who find the book lacking in certain areas. They criticize Skidmore's writing style, claiming it to be dry and academic, making it difficult to fully engage with the material. Some also express disappointment with the book's lack of coherence and organization, finding it challenging to follow the narrative. Additionally, some argue that the book fails to delve deeply enough into certain topics and does not provide a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter.

Several reviewers note that while "Black into White" offers valuable historical insights, it may not appeal to a wide audience. They suggest that the book is better suited for those with a specific interest in Brazilian history or race relations.

Lastly, there are readers who have mixed feelings about the book. They appreciate Skidmore's knowledge and dedication to the subject matter but also find the text overwhelming and dense. These readers suggest that multiple readings may be necessary to fully grasp the content of the book.

In summary, "Black into White" receives a range of reviews. While some readers appreciate its educational value and thorough research, others criticize the writing style and organization of the book. Prospective readers should consider their own interests and preferences before deciding whether to pick up this book.

BlackIntoWhite BookReview MustRead