Brokeback Mountain: Story to Screenplay : Book Review

Annie Proulx's "Brokeback Mountain" is an emotionally gripping novella that delves into the complexities of forbidden love. Set against the backdrop of the 1960s, the story follows Ennis Del Mar and Jack Twist, two ranch hands who find themselves unexpectedly drawn to one another during a summer job in Wyoming. What begins as a chance encounter evolves into a profound and passionate relationship that spans decades.

Proulx's writing style is simple yet incredibly powerful, painting a vivid portrayal of the rugged landscape and the characters' inner turmoil. Through her words, she captures the palpable tension and secrecy that often surrounded same-sex relationships during that time, allowing readers to feel the intense longing and fear experienced by Ennis and Jack. Additionally, the use of regional dialects adds an authentic touch, further immersing us in the era and setting.

One of the novel's notable strengths lies in its exploration of masculinity and the societal expectations that often constrain individuals. Ennis and Jack's inability to openly express their love due to societal norms and personal fears showcases the detrimental impact of societal pressure. Their internal struggles make their story all the more heartrending and relatable.

Furthermore, Proulx's character development is exceptional. Ennis and Jack are flawed and multi-dimensional individuals, each grappling with their own internal battles and insecurities. The raw and authentic portrayal of these characters allows readers to easily empathize with their struggles. Their love story is captivating, possessing both beauty and heartache, leaving an indelible mark on those who embark on their journey.

Overall, "Brokeback Mountain" is a powerful and thought-provoking tale that explores love, loss, and the constraints imposed by society. Proulx's masterful storytelling and well-crafted characters create an emotional journey that lingers long after the book is closed. This novella reminds us that love can bring both immense joy and profound pain, and that the choices we make when faced with societal pressure can have far-reaching consequences.

What are readers saying?

"Brokeback Mountain" is a highly acclaimed novel known for its powerful and moving story revolving around two cowboys, Ennis and Jack, who find themselves in a forbidden love affair against the backdrop of mid-20th-century rural America. Written by Annie Proulx, this book has received significant attention and garnered a mix of positive and negative reviews from readers on the popular platform, Goodreads.

Many readers praised the book for its rich and evocative storytelling, appreciating its ability to transport them to the rugged landscapes of Wyoming through vivid descriptions. Ennis and Jack, the complex and well-developed characters, were highly regarded for their emotional depth and the challenges they faced in a society that rejected their love. The exploration of themes such as love, identity, and societal constraints was also applauded for its thought-provoking nature.

However, some readers felt that the story lacked depth and character development, leaving them feeling disconnected from the protagonists. Additionally, a few reviewers expressed disappointment with the ending, finding it abrupt and leaving unanswered questions. Some readers also mentioned that the narrative was slow-paced, affecting their engagement with the book.

Despite these criticisms, the majority of readers found "Brokeback Mountain" to be a poignant and impactful read. Many appreciated its portrayal of homosexuality during a time when it was considered taboo, highlighting the personal struggles faced by Ennis and Jack. The book's ability to evoke a wide range of emotions from heartache to hope was also highly praised.

Overall, "Brokeback Mountain" remains a highly regarded work of fiction that elicits strong and diverse reactions from readers. While it may have fallen short in certain aspects for some, its beautiful storytelling, compelling characters, and the exploration of forbidden love in a repressive society continue to resonate with readers.

BrokebackMountain LoveisLove BookRecommendation