Brooklyn's Dodgers: The Bums, the Borough, and the Best of Baseball, 1947-1957 : Book Review

Carl E. Prince's "Brooklyn's Dodgers: The Bums, the Borough, and the Best of Baseball" takes readers on an enthralling journey through the captivating history of the Brooklyn Dodgers baseball team. Prince skillfully intertwines a narrative that not only explores the team's iconic players and moments but also delves into the social and cultural significance of the Dodgers within Brooklyn. With a comprehensive account of the team's rise, struggles, and eventual transition to Los Angeles, this book is a must-read for baseball enthusiasts and fans of Brooklyn's rich history.

One of the remarkable aspects of Prince's writing is his ability to bring the characters and events to life. Through meticulous research and attention to detail, readers are transported back to a time when the Dodgers reigned supreme in Brooklyn. Whether it's recounting Jackie Robinson's ground-breaking entry into major league baseball or highlighting the intense rivalry with the New York Yankees, Prince captures the excitement and passion that surrounded the team.

Furthermore, "Brooklyn's Dodgers" goes beyond on-field action and explores the inner workings of the team and the individuals behind the scenes. From the dynamic owner Walter O'Malley to the legendary manager Leo Durocher, Prince provides an insightful look at the personalities and decisions that shaped the Dodgers' enduring legacy. This multi-dimensional approach adds depth to the narrative and helps readers gain a profound understanding of the team's impact on Brooklyn and the sport as a whole.

In addition to the sport, Prince examines the wider social and cultural context in which the Dodgers existed. He explores how the team's integration with Jackie Robinson and other African American players challenged racial segregation and triggered crucial conversations about civil rights. By placing the Dodgers within a broader historical framework, Prince elevates the book beyond a mere sports story and emphasizes its larger significance.

Overall, "Brooklyn's Dodgers: The Bums, the Borough, and the Best of Baseball" is an engaging and comprehensive account of the iconic baseball team's history. Prince's captivating writing style, meticulous research, and thoughtful exploration of the team's social and cultural impact make this book a must-read for both baseball enthusiasts and history enthusiasts alike.

What are readers saying?

The book "Brooklyn's Dodgers" by Carl E. Prince has received a range of reviews, with readers expressing both praise and criticism. Many readers have praised the book for its extensive historical account and engaging storytelling. They appreciate that Prince has conducted thorough research and is knowledgeable about the Brooklyn Dodgers baseball team. Readers find the book to be captivating and informative, especially if they are fans of baseball and sports history.

However, there are some readers who are disappointed with the book's writing style. They feel that the narrative is dry and lacks engaging storytelling. Some mention that the book focuses too much on statistical data and fails to bring the characters and events to life. This disconnect from the story and its impact leads to a diminished enjoyment of the book.

Another criticism is the lack of depth in certain areas of the book. Readers feel that Prince misses opportunities to explore the social and cultural dynamics surrounding the team, as well as delve into the personal lives of the players. This lack of exploration prevents the book from providing a more comprehensive and nuanced account of the Brooklyn Dodgers' history, according to these readers.

One positive aspect of the book mentioned by several reviewers is the inclusion of photographs and illustrations. These visuals are seen as valuable additions that enhance the reading experience and help readers to further immerse themselves in the history of the Brooklyn Dodgers.

Overall, the reviews for "Brooklyn's Dodgers" by Carl E. Prince are varied. While some readers appreciate the detailed historical information and engaging storytelling, others criticize the writing style and lack of depth. Ultimately, readers with a keen interest in baseball history may find this book to be a worthwhile read, while those seeking a more dynamic and comprehensive narrative may be left wanting more.

BrooklynDodgers BaseballHistory SportsLegends