C'Est Comment L'Amerique : Book Review

"C'est Comment l'Amérique?" is a captivating memoir by Frank McCourt, where he recounts his experiences as an Irish immigrant in the United States. McCourt's skillful storytelling and heartfelt narrative provide an honest and compelling account of the triumphs and challenges he faced while pursuing the American Dream.

The book takes us on McCourt's incredible journey, starting from his impoverished upbringing in Limerick to his aspirations for a better life in America. Through his keen observations and engaging writing style, McCourt offers a unique perspective on the struggles faced by new immigrants. His vivid descriptions of city life and the cultural shocks he encountered provide readers with an immersive reading experience.

What makes "C'est Comment l'Amérique?" stand out is McCourt's ability to infuse humor into the grim realities he encountered. His dry wit and keen sense of irony bring a lightness to the often-difficult subject matter. Through this, McCourt explores themes of identity, resilience, and the pursuit of a brighter future.

The memoir also shines a light on the people who shaped McCourt's American experience. From his unwavering mother to the eclectic individuals he encountered along the way, each character adds depth to McCourt's narrative. The book not only tells McCourt's personal story but also provides insight into the broader immigrant experience, showcasing the challenges faced by those who leave their homes in search of a better life.

In conclusion, "C'est Comment l'Amérique?" is a powerful and poignant memoir that chronicles Frank McCourt's personal journey while shedding light on the larger immigrant experience. McCourt's raw and honest storytelling, combined with his sharp wit, make this book a compelling read for anyone interested in the complexities of American immigration and the resilience of the human spirit.

What are readers saying?

Frank McCourt's book "C'est Comment l'Amérique," written in French, has garnered both praise and criticism from readers. The book chronicles the author's journey as an immigrant in America. Here is a summary of the reviews:

1. Positive Reviews: Many readers commended McCourt's storytelling skills and his authentic portrayal of the immigrant experience. They found the book relatable and insightful, shedding light on the challenges faced by newcomers in a foreign land. McCourt's engaging and heartfelt writing style was also highly regarded.

2. Negative Reviews: Some readers expressed disappointment, claiming that the book did not live up to their expectations. They felt that the narrative lacked coherence and depth. These reviewers believed that the book did not provide sufficient details about the author's specific experiences in America, leaving them wanting for more substance.

3. Comparisons to McCourt's other works: Several readers drew comparisons between "C'est Comment l'Amérique" and McCourt's previous novels, particularly "Angela's Ashes," and found it to be lacking in comparison. They believed that McCourt's earlier works had a stronger emotional impact and more captivating storyline. Consequently, these reviewers considered "C'est Comment l'Amérique" to be a lesser version of the author's previous writings.

4. Cultural insights: Many readers appreciated McCourt's cultural observations in the book. His reflections on American society and the contrast with his Irish heritage were intriguing and thought-provoking. Some reviewers noted that the book served as a reminder of the diversity and challenges faced by immigrants in the United States.

CEstCommentLAmérique FrenchLiterature ContemporaryFiction