Christmas in Other Lands : Book Review

"Christmas in Other Lands" is a captivating and informative book that takes readers on a magical journey around the world to discover how different cultures celebrate the holiday season. Written by Janet McDonnell, this heartwarming book provides vivid descriptions and stunning illustrations that bring to life the diverse traditions, customs, and festivities observed in various countries during Christmas.

From the very beginning, McDonnell immerses readers in the enchanting celebrations of Mexico, where the Posadas reenactment of Mary and Joseph's search for shelter takes center stage. The author expertly captures the joy and vibrancy of this event, allowing readers to feel the excitement and witness the heartfelt atmosphere.

Continuing the journey, McDonnell explores Christmas traditions in Germany, Sweden, and Russia, among other countries. She skillfully highlights the significance of customs such as Germany's Christmas markets and Sweden's delightful St. Lucia Day celebrations. Additionally, the book uncovers lesser-known traditions, shedding light on the important role that Father Christmas plays in Russia.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its ability to foster cultural understanding and appreciation. McDonnell not only presents the various customs but also provides historical and cultural context, enabling readers to gain a deeper understanding of each tradition. This serves as a reminder that Christmas is more than just gifts and decorations, but a celebration of the rich tapestry of diverse customs that make the holiday season special worldwide.

Overall, "Christmas in Other Lands" by Janet McDonnell is an engaging and enlightening book that celebrates the global spirit of Christmas. With its captivating illustrations and informative descriptions, it offers readers a delightful glimpse into the unique traditions and festivities observed in different cultures during this joyous time of year. It serves as a beautiful reminder of the unity, compassion, and appreciation for diversity that exists in our world.

What are readers saying?

The book "Christmas in Other Lands" by Janet McDonnell has garnered a range of responses from readers. Some found it to be a valuable and educational read, praising its exploration of diverse Christmas customs worldwide. They commended the author for her detailed explanations and captivating facts about various countries' holiday traditions. These readers considered the book a valuable resource for learning about different cultures and expanding their knowledge of Christmas celebrations beyond their own experiences.

However, there were others who were disappointed with the book's execution. They felt that the information provided was surface-level and lacked depth. These readers desired a more thorough exploration of the countries and their distinctive Christmas customs, feeling that the book was too brief and lacking substance. They wished for more detailed explanations and a deeper analysis of the traditions discussed.

Additionally, some reviewers criticized the book for having outdated content. They felt that it did not accurately reflect the current diversity and inclusiveness of Christmas celebrations. These readers were disappointed by the book's omission or misrepresentation of certain cultures and traditions. They felt that the portrayal lacked accuracy and sensitivity.

On the other hand, there were readers who appreciated the book's nostalgic feel. They enjoyed the author's storytelling style, which reminded them of traditional Christmas books from the past. These readers felt a sense of warmth and nostalgia as they read about different Christmas customs, appreciating the book's ability to evoke a holiday spirit.

Overall, "Christmas in Other Lands" by Janet McDonnell elicited mixed responses from readers. While some appreciated its educational value and the author's storytelling style, others felt it lacked depth and accuracy. Ultimately, readers' opinions on the book will likely depend on their expectations and desires for a comprehensive exploration of different Christmas traditions worldwide.

ChristmasInOtherLands HolidayReads ChristmasBooks