Clement Greenberg: A Critic's Collection : Book Review

"Clement Greenberg: A Life" by Karen Wilkin provides a detailed examination of the life and career of one of the most influential art critics of the 20th century. With meticulous research and compelling storytelling, Wilkin presents a must-read biography for art enthusiasts, historians, and anyone interested in the development of modern art.

The book delves into Greenberg's upbringing, early influences, and his journey from struggling writer to becoming the champion of Abstract Expressionism. Wilkin sheds light on Greenberg's relationships with pivotal artists like Jackson Pollock and Willem de Kooning, offering valuable insights into the cultural and artistic landscape of the time.

One of the standout features of this biography is Wilkin's exploration of Greenberg's role as a taste-maker and his impact on the art world. She dissects his controversial theories regarding medium specificity and his role in promoting American art as superior to European art. With her deep analysis, readers gain a greater understanding of the context and significance of Greenberg's critical essays that continue to shape the discourse surrounding modern art.

What sets Wilkin's biography apart is her ability to present a balanced portrayal of Greenberg. She acknowledges his flaws and contradictions while recognizing his undeniable influence on the art world. By delving into his personal life, struggles, friendships, and feuds, Wilkin offers a nuanced perspective on this complex figure.

Overall, "Clement Greenberg: A Life" is a meticulously researched and engaging biography that offers a comprehensive exploration of Greenberg's life, work, and lasting legacy. Wilkin's scholarly approach, combined with her accessible writing style, makes this book a valuable resource for anyone seeking to understand the evolution of modern art and the role of influential critics like Greenberg.

What are readers saying?

Karen Wilkin's book "Clement Greenberg: A Critic's Collection" has received a range of reviews from readers. Some readers commend Wilkin's comprehensive overview of Greenberg's art collection and find it to be a valuable resource for understanding Greenberg's taste and interests as a critic. They appreciate Wilkin's curation of the collection's images, which allows readers to visualize the artworks alongside her commentary.

However, other readers express disappointment with the lack of depth and analysis in Wilkin's writing. They believe the book reads more like a catalog than a scholarly exploration of Greenberg's collection. Some were hoping for a deeper examination of the theoretical implications of the artwork and its alignment with Greenberg's influential modernism theories.

In addition, some readers find Wilkin's writing style to be dry and detached, lacking enthusiasm and failing to engage the reader effectively. They desired a more personal and dynamic perspective on the artworks and their significance, rather than a detached approach.

Nevertheless, many readers appreciate the inclusion of high-quality images of the artworks in the book. They believe the visual representation enhances the reading experience and provides a better understanding of Greenberg's taste and the context in which he critiqued art.

Overall, Karen Wilkin's "Clement Greenberg: A Critic's Collection" receives mixed reviews. While some readers value the book's comprehensive documentation of Greenberg's collection and the inclusion of high-quality images, others criticize the lack of critical analysis and the detached writing style.

ClementGreenberg ModernArt ArtCriticism