Crime and Social Control in a Changing China : Book Review

"Crime and Social Control in a Changing China" by Steven F. Messner provides an in-depth exploration of the complex relationship between crime and social control in the midst of China's rapid societal transformations. The book delves into various dimensions of crime, ranging from street crime to corruption and organized crime, shedding light on their causes and consequences.

One of the notable aspects of Messner's analysis is his examination of the role of the Chinese government in crime control. He explores how the state's efforts to maintain stability and promote economic development influence crime rates and control measures. Moreover, the book emphasizes the interplay between formal and informal social control mechanisms, encompassing both state-sanctioned practices and community-based approaches.

Messner pays particular attention to the changes in social control policies and strategies in China over time. He investigates the impact of China's transition towards a market-oriented economy and the subsequent shifts in social norms and values. By analyzing these transformations, Messner provides valuable insights into the intersection of social change, economic development, and crime patterns.

The interdisciplinary approach taken by Messner, integrating criminology, sociology, and political science, lends depth and richness to his analysis. Through rigorous research and insightful analysis, he examines the social, economic, and political factors that contribute to crime patterns and social control dynamics in China.

"Crime and Social Control in a Changing China" offers a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the complexities surrounding crime and social control in modern China. The book serves as an invaluable resource for academics, researchers, and policymakers alike, offering valuable insights into crime patterns and control strategies in the context of China's ongoing transformation. Messner's work contributes significantly to the growing body of literature on crime and social control in China, guiding our understanding of this ever-evolving landscape.

What are readers saying?

The reception of Steven F. Messner's book, "Criminal and Social Control in a Changing China," has been varied among readers. While some reviewers praised the insightful analysis and comprehensive coverage of the subject matter, others felt that the book lacked depth and failed to present a clear argument.

Many readers appreciated the book's thorough analysis of crime trends and social control in China. They found Messner's research to be thorough and well-documented, providing a comprehensive overview of the issues at hand. The author was commended for shedding light on the complexities of the Chinese criminal justice system and its relationship with broader social issues.

However, some reviewers criticized the book for lacking a concise argument. They felt that Messner failed to provide a strong thesis or central theme throughout the book, making it difficult to follow his line of reasoning. Additionally, some readers noted that the book may be too academically focused, potentially limiting its accessibility for a general audience.

Furthermore, a few reviewers found the writing style to be dry and overly technical. They expressed disappointment with the lack of engaging storytelling or personal anecdotes to support the analysis. This hindered their ability to connect with the material and maintain interest in the book.

Another point of contention among reviewers was the book's organization. Some felt that the chapters were not well-structured or cohesive, resulting in a disjointed reading experience. They suggested that a clearer framework would have improved the overall flow and understanding of the material.

CrimeAndSocialControl ChangingChina ChineseCrime