"Crisis of the House Divided" by Harry V. Jaffa offers a compelling and thought-provoking examination of the political and moral issues that ultimately led to the American Civil War. Jaffa, a respected scholar and historian, delves deep into the ideology and arguments of key figures such as Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas, providing insightful analysis and engaging with their ideas in a rigorous manner.
The book explores the fundamental conflict between the pro-slavery stance of the South and the anti-slavery sentiment that emerged in the North. According to Jaffa, this conflict could not have been resolved through compromise or negotiation, as it was rooted in a clash of fundamental moral values. By drawing extensively from Lincoln's speeches and writings, Jaffa demonstrates how Lincoln viewed the preservation of the Union and the abolition of slavery as inseparable goals.
One particular highlight of Jaffa's analysis is his exploration of the Lincoln-Douglas debates, which shed light on the contrasting visions of America's future presented by these two politicians. Jaffa emphasizes the significance of Lincoln's commitment to the principles of the Declaration of Independence, particularly equality and natural rights. In contrast, he critiques Douglas' theory of popular sovereignty, arguing that it failed to address the moral question of slavery.
Available on Audible
Throughout the book, Jaffa demonstrates a deep understanding of the complex historical and philosophical context in which the crisis unfolded. He provides a comprehensive and nuanced analysis of the events and ideas that shaped the nation at a critical juncture in its history. "Crisis of the House Divided" is an essential read for anyone interested in understanding the origins and implications of the Civil War, as well as gaining insight into the political thought of Abraham Lincoln.
In conclusion, "Crisis of the House Divided" by Harry V. Jaffa offers a compelling examination of the political and moral issues that led to the American Civil War. Jaffa's rigorous analysis and insightful exploration of key figures and their ideas provide a comprehensive understanding of the complexities of this crucial period in American history. This book is a valuable resource for anyone seeking to delve deeper into the origins and implications of the Civil War and gain greater insight into the political thought of Abraham Lincoln.
What are readers saying?
"Crisis of the House Divided" by Harry V. Jaffa has received a range of reviews, both positive and negative. The book delves into the political philosophy of Abraham Lincoln and offers valuable insights into the issues surrounding the Civil War.
Many reviewers commend Jaffa for his thorough analysis of Lincoln's political thinking. They appreciate the author's meticulous research and his ability to convey complex ideas in an accessible manner. Readers admire Jaffa's defense of Lincoln's principles of equality and his arguments against slavery. They find his insights enlightening and commendable.
However, some readers find the book to be overly dense and academic, making it challenging to fully comprehend the concepts presented. They believe that prior knowledge of political philosophy and American history is necessary to fully appreciate and understand Jaffa's arguments. Some reviewers express disappointment with what they perceive as a one-sided portrayal of Lincoln, suggesting that Jaffa fails to consider alternative viewpoints or engage with potential criticisms of Lincoln's policies.
One common point made by both positive and negative reviewers is the book's length and level of detail. While some appreciate the depth of Jaffa's analysis, others find it excessive, leading to repetition and a lack of focus. They suggest that the book could have been more concise without sacrificing its core arguments.
Opinions on Jaffa's writing style are varied. Some readers find his prose clear and engaging, making it easy to follow his line of reasoning. Others, however, criticize Jaffa's writing for being dry and lacking a cohesive structure, which makes it challenging to stay engaged with the material.
CrisisOfTheHouseDivided LincolnHistory PoliticalDissension