Cuentos inconclusos de Númenor y la Tierra Media : Book Review

"Cuentos inconclusos de Númenor y la Tierra Media" is a compelling compilation of unfinished stories penned by J.R.R. Tolkien, the renowned author of the beloved "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy. This collection serves as a window into the vast and intricate mythos and history of Middle-earth, offering captivating narratives that were left incomplete at the time of Tolkien's passing.

Within the pages of this anthology, readers are treated to tales that span across different eras of Middle-earth, starting from the creation of the world to pivotal events occurring during the Third Age. Each story grants readers deeper insights into the characters, cultures, and events that shaped Tolkien's masterfully crafted universe.

A particular highlight of this book is the tragic story of Númenor, a magnificent civilization that crumbled due to the arrogance and insatiable desire for immortality among its inhabitants. Through the downfall of Númenor, Tolkien intricately explores themes of power, corruption, and the dire consequences of hubris.

Another notable narrative is the tale of Aldarion and Erendis, which delves into the complexities of love, pride, and the clash of different cultures. This bittersweet story provides a more intimate view of the lives of characters in Middle-earth and showcases Tolkien's remarkable ability to interweave human emotions into a fantastical realm.

Though the stories in "Cuentos inconclusos de Númenor y la Tierra Media" remain unfinished, the brilliance of Tolkien's storytelling shines throughout. The depth of his world-building and the complexity of his characters make for a captivating read for fans of his works, immersing them further into the intricate tapestry of Middle-earth. However, it is worth noting that those unfamiliar with Tolkien's other writings may find it challenging to fully appreciate the subtle nuances and references present within these incomplete tales.

What are readers saying?

"Cuentos inconclusos de Númenor y la Tierra Media" by J.R.R. Tolkien has generated a mix of opinions among readers. Some praised the book for its detailed exploration of Tolkien's world, finding it captivating and engaging. They appreciated the additional insights into Middle-earth's history and mythology, as well as the intricate world-building and complex characters. These readers admired Tolkien's signature writing style, with its depth and richness.

However, other readers expressed disappointment, feeling that the stories lacked the cohesion and satisfaction found in Tolkien's other works like "The Hobbit" or "The Lord of the Rings." They saw the stories as fragmented, lacking a clear narrative structure. Some reviewers suggested that the book is better suited for readers already familiar with Tolkien's universe, as it may be challenging for newcomers to follow.

The presence of extensive footnotes and appendices in the book garnered mixed reactions. Some readers found them informative and helpful in understanding the stories, while others felt overwhelmed and believed they detracted from the reading experience. Some reviewers desired a more integrated approach, where the information seamlessly blended with the text.

Opinions on the book's prose style and language were divided as well. Some admired Tolkien's beautiful and poetic writing, which immersed them in a sense of wonder. However, others found it dense and difficult to read, especially when combined with the complex names and terminology used in the stories.

Overall, "Cuentos inconclusos de Númenor y la Tierra Media" appears to be a book that appeals to fans of Tolkien's Middle-earth mythology, providing them with additional lore and stories within this beloved fictional universe. However, it may not be as accessible or engaging for readers who are not already familiar with Tolkien's works.

CuentosInconclusos TierraMedia FantasyBooks