Departures: Stories of Alternate History : Book Review

"Departures" by Harry Turtledove is a captivating collection of short stories that explores the theme of departure in various forms. Turtledove’s writing spans different genres, including alternate history and science fiction, keeping readers engaged throughout.

The book opens with "The Doctor's Coat," a story that imagines a world where the Germans won World War II. Turtledove's meticulous attention to detail and thorough research brings this alternate history to life, making it both intriguing and thought-provoking. The characters are well-developed, and the plot keeps readers guessing until the very end.

Another standout story is "Islands in the Sea," which is set in an alternate present where Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines are independent nations. Turtledove's imagination shines through as he explores the tensions and alliances between these countries. The political intrigue is masterfully woven into the narrative, providing an engaging and unpredictable read.

Turtledove also delves into the realm of science fiction with stories like "The Road Not Taken" and "Occupation Duty." In these tales, he explores the consequences of human encounters with extraterrestrial beings. Turtledove's ability to create unique and believable worlds is apparent, drawing readers into different realities with each turn of the page.

"Departures" is a testament to Turtledove's skill as a writer. Each story is crafted with care, showcasing his ability to create compelling characters, intricate plots, and immersive settings. Whether you are a fan of alternate history, science fiction, or simply enjoy well-written short stories, this collection is sure to captivate and entertain.

What are readers saying?

Harry Turtledove's book "Departures" has received a range of reviews from readers, with some finding it enjoyable and thought-provoking, while others were disappointed with the stories and writing style.

Positive reviews often highlight Turtledove's skill in creating vivid and engaging worlds within each story. Readers appreciated his imaginative concepts and the unique perspectives presented in each tale. The strong character development also allowed readers to connect with the protagonists and become immersed in their journeys.

On the other hand, negative reviews criticized the lack of cohesion and direction in the book. Some readers felt that the stories were disjointed and lacked the depth they had anticipated. They also mentioned that the writing style could be repetitive and deviated from Turtledove's usual standards.

A common thread throughout the reviews was the varying quality of the stories. Some readers praised certain stories as exceptional, while others found some to be lackluster and forgettable. This inconsistency in the collection made it challenging for readers to form a consistent opinion on the book as a whole.

Additionally, a few readers felt that "Departures" lacked a clear overarching theme or message. They struggled to find meaning in the individual stories and noticed a lack of cohesion between them.

DeparturesBook BookRecommendations MustRead