"Der falsch vermessene Mensch" (The Mismeasure of Man) by Stephen Jay Gould is a captivating exploration of the concept of intelligence and its measurement throughout history. Gould challenges the simplistic notion of intelligence as a fixed and quantifiable trait, arguing for a more nuanced understanding of human intellectual capabilities.
Gould delves into the origins of intelligence testing in the 19th century and uncovers the biases and limitations that have distorted our understanding of intelligence. He meticulously examines the flawed methodologies and assumptions that underpin these tests, highlighting the cultural and societal biases that have influenced the results. In particular, Gould exposes the dark side of eugenics, where IQ tests were misused to perpetuate racial superiority, leading to devastating consequences.
One of the strengths of Gould's work is his ability to make complex scientific concepts accessible to a general audience. Through engaging storytelling and thorough analysis of historical and scientific evidence, he challenges common beliefs about intelligence, warning against reductionism and stereotyping. He encourages readers to critically question the underlying assumptions and biases of intelligence testing, emphasizing that human potential cannot be neatly measured by a single metric.
Available on Audible
"Der falsch vermessene Mensch" is a thought-provoking book that prompts readers to reevaluate their understanding of human intelligence. Gould's insightful analysis and extensive research shed light on the history and politics of intelligence testing, exposing the dangers of using these tests to make broad judgments about individuals or groups. It serves as a reminder to approach the concept of intelligence with humility and to value the diversity of human abilities.
Stephen Jay Gould's book "Der falsch vermessenene Mensch" (translated as "The Mismeasure of Man") has generated a range of reactions from readers. While some commend Gould's comprehensive exploration of the history and deficiencies in measuring human intelligence, others find his writing style excessively technical and difficult to follow.
Many readers praise Gould for his meticulous research and in-depth analysis of intelligence testing. They find his arguments compelling, particularly his critique of the entrenched assumptions and biases that have influenced the field. These readers appreciate Gould's challenge to the belief in a single, quantifiable measure of intelligence, as he advocates for a more nuanced understanding.
However, some reviewers criticize Gould's writing for its density and lack of accessibility. They feel that his excessive use of scientific jargon and technical terminology makes the book challenging for the average reader. These individuals desire a more concise and user-friendly presentation of the complex topics addressed in the book.
The inclusion of detailed historical accounts and case studies is a divisive aspect among reviewers. Some readers appreciate the enrichment provided by understanding the evolution of intelligence testing over time. On the other hand, others find these sections repetitive and excessively long, desiring a greater focus on the central arguments.
In terms of organization, some reviewers commend Gould for presenting his arguments in a logical and coherent manner, effectively building his case against misguided assumptions in intelligence testing. However, a few readers find that the book lacks a clear overarching structure, making it difficult to follow the flow of arguments.
DerFalschVermesseneMensch MenschlicheFehleinschätzung GebrocheneVermessung