Die Islamistische Bewegung In Jordanien Und Palästina 1945 1989 : Book Review

"Die Islamistische Bewegung in Jordanien und Palästina: 1945-1989" by Denis Engelleder is a meticulously researched book that delves into the complex world of Islamist movements in Jordan and Palestine from 1945 to 1989. Engelleder skillfully explores the historical, political, and social factors that influenced the emergence and development of these movements, providing a nuanced understanding of their ideologies and impact.

Engelleder begins by examining the historical context in which these Islamist movements arose, highlighting the post-colonial era and the rise of nationalist sentiments. He delves into how these movements in Jordan and Palestine navigated the challenges presented by the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the Arab-Israeli wars, tracing their transformation from nationalist to Islamist ideologies.

Through extensive research and analysis, Engelleder sheds light on the ideologies, objectives, and organizational structures of these movements. He delves into their religious foundations and explores their efforts to establish Islamic states in Jordan and Palestine. Engelleder also highlights the similarities and differences between the Islamist movements in the two regions, emphasizing their unique characteristics and motivations.

The book offers valuable insights into the socio-political dynamics of Jordan and Palestine during this period, providing a deeper understanding of the factors that shaped religious and political movements in the region. Engelleder explores the influence of international events, such as the Iranian Revolution and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, on these Islamist movements, showcasing their transnational connections and influences.

Overall, "Die Islamistische Bewegung in Jordanien und Palästina: 1945-1989" contributes significantly to our understanding of the Islamist movements in Jordan and Palestine. Engelleder's analysis is both thorough and thought-provoking, making it a recommended read for anyone interested in Middle Eastern history and the dynamics of Islamic movements.

What are readers saying?

Denis Engelleder's book, "Die Islamistische Bewegung in Jordanien und Palästina 1945-1989," has received a mixture of feedback from readers. The first group of reviewers appreciate the book's detailed analysis and extensive research. They commend Engelleder's ability to provide a thorough historical account of the Islamist movement in Jordan and Palestine during the specified time frame. The author's use of primary sources and interviews adds credibility to the work, making it an essential resource for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of the Islamist movement in the region.

On the other hand, some readers express disappointment in the book's writing style and structure. They find the text to be dense and overly academic, making it challenging to follow at times. These reviewers suggest that Engelleder's work may be better suited for scholars and experts in the field, rather than the general public. Additionally, a few readers feel that the book lacks a clear focus or argument, making it difficult to grasp the main thesis throughout.

Another point raised by reviewers is the book's limited scope. Some readers criticize Engelleder for solely focusing on the Islamist movement in Jordan and Palestine without providing a broader regional context or considering other significant factors that influenced the movement. These reviewers argue that a more comprehensive analysis would have offered a more well-rounded understanding of the subject.

Furthermore, some readers note that the book's publication date may impact its relevance to current events. As the book was published in 1996, it may not include more recent developments in the Islamist movement. Reviewers suggest supplementing the book with more up-to-date sources or combining it with other works on the topic.

In conclusion, while Denis Engelleder's "Die Islamistische Bewegung in Jordanien und Palästina 1945-1989" is praised for its meticulous research and historical analysis, some readers raise concerns about its writing style, lack of focus, and limited scope. Despite these criticisms, the book remains a valuable resource for scholars and individuals seeking a thorough understanding of the Islamist movement in Jordan and Palestine during the specified time period.

IslamistischeBewegung Jordanien Palästina