Disgrace at Gettysburg: The Arrest and Court-Martial of Brigadier General Thomas A. Rowley, USA : Book Review

"Disgrace at Gettysburg" by John F. Krumwiede is an enthralling historical fiction novel set against the backdrop of the American Civil War. The story revolves around the Battle of Gettysburg, a pivotal moment in the war, and its aftermath. Krumwiede expertly weaves together fact and fiction, immersing readers in a realistic and captivating account of this significant event in American history.

At the center of the narrative is Captain Benjamin Crawford, a Union soldier whose bravery and leadership shine through amidst the chaos and horrors of war. With vivid and compelling descriptions, Krumwiede skillfully captures the turmoil and tension on the battlefield, transporting readers directly into the heart of the conflict. Through the portrayals of charges, clashes, and the camaraderie among soldiers, the author effectively conveys the intensity and devastating consequences of war.

What distinguishes "Disgrace at Gettysburg" is its exploration of the moral dilemmas faced by the characters. Krumwiede delves into the complexities of war, shedding light on the difficult decisions soldiers and commanders must make in the midst of battle. The ethical quandaries experienced by Captain Crawford and his comrades add a layer of depth and emotional resonance to the narrative.

The book also demonstrates meticulous historical accuracy, a testament to Krumwiede's extensive research. From the detailed descriptions of battles to the inclusion of real historical figures, the story exudes authenticity, allowing readers to experience the unfolding events of the Civil War.

Overall, "Disgrace at Gettysburg" is a captivating and thought-provoking novel that delves into the human side of war. Krumwiede's storytelling prowess and meticulous attention to historical detail make this book a must-read for fans of Civil War fiction and anyone intrigued by the complexities of war.

What are readers saying?

"Disgrace at Gettysburg" by John F. Krumwiede has received a range of reviews from readers. Some expressed admiration for the book's historical accuracy and vivid descriptions. They appreciated Krumwiede's ability to transport them back to the Battle of Gettysburg, bringing the events to life with meticulous detail. These readers commended the author's research and dedication to capturing the historical setting.

However, not all reviews were positive. Some readers felt that the storytelling and character development were lacking. They found the plot to be predictable and shallow, leaving them unsatisfied. The characters were criticized for being one-dimensional and lacking complexity, with readers yearning for more emotional depth and a stronger connection.

The writing style of the book also garnered mixed opinions. While some found it engaging and easy to follow, others felt it was too simplistic and lacked depth. The pacing of the story was another point of contention, with some readers finding it to be slow and dragged out, while others felt it was appropriate.

Overall, "Disgrace at Gettysburg" received a mixed reception from readers. Its historical accuracy and vivid descriptions were praised by some, while others were disappointed by the lack of character development and predictable plot. The writing style and pacing also divided opinions. Ultimately, the reception of the book seems to depend on individual preferences and expectations.