Elinor & Marianne : Book Review

"Elinor Marianne" by Emma Tennant is a modern-day retelling of Jane Austen's beloved novel, "Sense and Sensibility." This contemporary adaptation takes readers on a journey through the lives of two sisters, Elinor and Marianne, as they navigate the complexities of love, family, and society in modern England. Tennant's skillful storytelling captures the essence of Austen's original work while infusing it with her own unique and refreshing twists.

One of the standout qualities of Tennant's adaptation is her ability to delve into the intricate dynamics of sisterhood. Elinor and Marianne's relationship is portrayed with depth and authenticity, allowing readers to truly invest in their journey. The contrasting personalities of the sisters, Elinor's rationality and Marianne's passion, are explored with great nuance, making them relatable and compelling characters. Tennant effectively demonstrates how their distinct approaches to love and life shape their individual paths to happiness.

The portrayal of love and romance in "Elinor Marianne" is another strong aspect of the book. Tennant adeptly captures the complexities and nuances of romantic relationships, particularly through the sisters' respective love interests. These romances are portrayed as realistic and believable, combining both passion and emotional depth. The author also delves into the impact of societal expectations and norms on these relationships, adding a thought-provoking layer to the story.

In addition to its compelling characters and exploration of relationships, "Elinor Marianne" captivates readers with Tennant's engaging and evocative writing style. Her prose is elegant and flows effortlessly, immersing readers in the vivid world she creates. The attention to detail in describing settings and atmosphere enhances the overall reading experience, successfully blending the modern setting with elements of Austen's era.

Overall, "Elinor Marianne" is a delightful retelling that pays homage to Austen's original work while offering a fresh and contemporary perspective. Emma Tennant's masterful characterization, exploration of love and relationships, and elegant writing style make for an engaging and enjoyable read. Whether readers are familiar with Austen's work or not, they will be captivated by this modern adaptation filled with timeless themes and relatable characters.

What are readers saying?

Elinor and Marianne by Emma Tennant is a contemporary reimagining of Jane Austen's timeless novel, Sense and Sensibility. The book has received a range of reviews from readers, with opinions spanning from highly positive to somewhat negative.

Many readers applaud Emma Tennant's fresh approach to Austen's beloved tale. They admire her modern and inventive portrayal of the characters and storyline. Tennant's writing is often described as vibrant and engaging, with a unique voice that adds an intriguing perspective to the narrative. These positive reviews acknowledge Tennant's successful updates to make the story relatable for today's readers while still capturing Austen's wit and social critique.

However, there are also readers who did not connect with Tennant's adaptation. They criticize her writing style as excessively contemporary and suggest that she takes too many liberties with Austen's original characters and plot. Some readers express disappointment, feeling that Tennant fails to replicate the elegance and sophistication of Austen's prose, resulting in a less charming and deep rendition of the novel. These less favorable reviews often convey a sense of dissatisfaction with the adaptation.

Overall, opinions on Elinor and Marianne by Emma Tennant are divided. While some readers appreciate the fresh perspective and modern take on Austen's classic, others believe that Tennant falls short of the original. If you are a fan of Austen eager to explore different interpretations of her works, Tennant's book may be a stimulating read. However, if you prefer a more faithful recreation of Sense and Sensibility, approaching this adaptation with caution might be advisable.