"Encounter" by Jane Yolen is a truly captivating and visually stunning children's book that presents a unique perspective on Christopher Columbus's encounter with the indigenous people of the Caribbean. Through the eyes of a young Taino boy named Juan, Yolen explores the emotions and consequences of Columbus's arrival in the New World.
Yolen's narrative effectively captures Juan's innocence and curiosity as he stumbles upon Columbus's ships and wonders about their nature. Juan's growing apprehension and concerns are portrayed with great sensitivity as he witnesses the devastating changes brought about by the Europeans, such as the destruction of the environment and the subjugation of his people.
One of the most striking aspects of "Encounter" is the exquisite artwork by David Shannon. The illustrations brilliantly depict the lush landscapes of the Caribbean and provide a powerful contrast between the Taino people and the Europeans. The use of Taino symbols and motifs adds an authentic touch and enhances the storytelling experience.
Available on Audible
Yolen's portrayal of Columbus is particularly noteworthy. Rather than presenting him as a one-dimensional hero or villain, she portrays him as a complex figure with conflicting motivations. This allows young readers to develop a critical perspective on history and encourages them to question the narratives they encounter.
Overall, "Encounter" is a valuable and captivating book that introduces young readers to the impact of European colonization on indigenous communities. With its engaging storytelling, breathtaking artwork, and thoughtful exploration of complex historical themes, this book is a must-read for children and adults alike. It offers a fresh and thought-provoking perspective on a well-known historical event, making it an essential addition to any library or home collection.
What are readers saying?
Jane Yolen's novel "Encounter" has garnered a range of opinions from readers, with some expressing admiration for the book's engaging narrative and Yolen's compelling writing style. These readers appreciated the author's skill in blending historical and fictional elements, as well as her meticulous attention to detail. They also praised the exploration of various perspectives and themes, including colonialism and cultural misunderstandings.
However, not all readers were satisfied with the book. One critic voiced disappointment with the predictable plot and lack of originality, feeling that the characters were underdeveloped and difficult to emotionally connect with. The pacing was also criticized for being slow and disjointed, leading to further dissatisfaction.
Despite its shortcomings, Yolen's writing style still managed to captivate some readers. They found her descriptions vivid and her prose engaging, which effectively brought the historical aspects of the story to life. These readers commended the author's ability to create atmospheric scenes and transport them to different time periods.
Nonetheless, there were also those who felt that the book lacked depth in terms of character development and emotional resonance. Connecting with the characters proved challenging, and some readers longed for more complexity and intricacy in the relationships portrayed.
In summary, Jane Yolen's novel "Encounter" elicited a mixture of positive and negative responses from readers. While some enjoyed the historical elements and Yolen's writing style, others found fault with the predictable plot and struggled to emotionally engage with the characters. Ultimately, reader satisfaction may depend on individual preferences for historical fiction and the importance placed on well-developed characters.
#Encounter #BookReview #MustRead