Esos cielos : Book Review

In "Esos cielos" by Bernardo Atxaga, readers are transported to a small village in the Basque Country during the Spanish Civil War. The story revolves around a young boy named Julen, who faces the challenges and injustices of war while also grappling with his own personal struggles.

Atxaga's skill as a writer shines through in his ability to effectively capture the atmosphere of the era. The vivid descriptions of the village and its inhabitants make readers feel as though they are right beside Julen, experiencing the same emotions and witnessing the same events. The turbulence and uncertainty of the Spanish Civil War are palpable throughout the novel.

The character development in "Esos cielos" is truly exceptional. Julen's journey from innocence to understanding is portrayed with eloquence, allowing readers to empathize deeply with his struggles. Atxaga creates multi-dimensional and relatable characters, adding depth to the story and keeping readers engaged.

The themes explored in this novel are both thought-provoking and relevant. Atxaga delves into the impact of war on individuals and communities, the power of friendship and loyalty, and the resilience of the human spirit. Through Julen's experiences, readers are prompted to reflect on the complexities of war and the lasting effects it can have on both individuals and society as a whole.

"Esos cielos" is a poignant and captivating novel that seamlessly weaves together history, personal growth, and social commentary. Atxaga's lyrical prose and vivid storytelling create a compelling narrative that lingers in the minds of readers long after they finish the book. Whether you have an interest in historical fiction or simply appreciate well-crafted novels, "Esos cielos" is a must-read.

What are readers saying?

"Esos cielos" by Bernardo Atxaga has received a mix of reviews from readers. Some found the book to be captivating and moving, while others were disappointed with the storytelling and development of the characters.

One reviewer praised Atxaga's ability to transport readers to another time and place with his vivid descriptions of the Basque countryside. The prose was deemed beautiful and lyrical, immersing readers in the setting. The author's portrayal of the characters' inner struggles and insecurities was also commended, adding depth to the story.

Another reader found the themes explored in "Esos cielos" to be thought-provoking and relevant. Atxaga delves into issues such as identity, memory, and the impact of history on individuals and society. The reviewer appreciated how the author intertwined these themes through different narrative threads, creating a rich and complex tapestry.

However, some readers felt that the book had a slow-paced plot and lacked direction. They found it difficult to become engaged with the story, resulting in the book feeling tedious to read. These reviewers were disappointed with the lack of a cohesive plot and felt that the story meandered without a clear purpose.

Additionally, some critics were unsatisfied with the character development in "Esos cielos." They found the protagonist to be unrelatable and underdeveloped, which affected their overall enjoyment of the book. The supporting characters were also seen as one-dimensional and lacking in depth, making it hard for readers to emotionally connect with them.

EsosCielosBook CelestialReading SkyHigh