Euripidean Polemic: The Trojan Women and the Function of Tragedy : Book Review

In "Euripidean Polemic" by Neil T. Croally, readers are taken on a captivating journey through the works of Euripides, a renowned tragedian from ancient Greece. This book offers a meticulous exploration of Euripides' plays, shedding light on their political and social commentary and their relevance to contemporary society.

Croally's extensive research and insightful analysis provide a comprehensive understanding of Euripides' works. The book begins by placing his plays in the context of Athens during the Peloponnesian War, highlighting the turbulent political climate in which they were written. By doing so, Croally skillfully reveals how Euripides used his plays as a platform to critique and challenge prevailing ideologies, touching on themes such as imperialism, gender relations, and the flaws of traditional mythological narratives.

One of the strengths of Croally's approach is its thoroughness. He not only analyzes the texts of Euripides, but also explores the historical context, literary techniques, and dramatic strategies employed by the playwright. This comprehensive analysis unveils the rhetorical devices used by Euripides to provoke thought, question societal norms, and engage his audience in conversations about morality and power.

Croally's writing style is both engaging and accessible, making the book suitable for scholars and general readers alike. By incorporating primary sources and quotes from Euripides' plays, accompanied by his own thoughtful interpretations, the author creates a well-rounded understanding of the polemical nature of Euripides' works.

Ultimately, "Euripidean Polemic" is a highly informative and thought-provoking book that offers valuable insights into the intellectual and political climate of ancient Greece, as well as the enduring relevance of Euripides' plays. Neil T. Croally's attention to detail, thorough research, and lucid writing style make this book an essential read for anyone interested in classical literature and the power of drama as a means of social critique.

What are readers saying?

Neil T. Croally's book "Euripidean Polemic" has garnered a variety of responses from its readers. This book delves into the works of the ancient Greek tragedian Euripides, specifically exploring his use of polemic in his plays. Let's summarize the reviews:

1. Positive reviews: Many readers highly praised "Euripidean Polemic" for its scholarly and comprehensive approach to analyzing Euripides' work. They commended Croally for his ability to unravel the complexities of polemic within the plays, providing valuable insights into the dramatic techniques employed by the ancient playwright. These reviewers found the book to be thoroughly researched and informative, contributing to a deeper understanding of Euripides and his significant contribution to Greek tragedy.

2. Mixed reviews: Some readers had mixed feelings about the book. They acknowledged the author's expertise in the subject matter but felt that the writing style was excessively academic and difficult to follow. These reviewers suggested that the book may be better suited for students or individuals with a strong background in Greek literature and rhetoric.

3. Critical reviews: A few readers expressed disappointment with "Euripidean Polemic." They criticized the book for its excessive density and lack of accessibility to those not already well-versed in the subject. These reviewers found the writing style overly technical, lacking clarity, and making it challenging for them to engage with the content.

4. Appreciation for scholarship: Despite some reservations, many readers acknowledged the value of Croally's research and scholarship in "Euripidean Polemic." They recognized the book's contributions to the field of classical studies and commended the author for his deep understanding of Euripides' works. These reviewers believed that it would be a valuable resource for academics and researchers interested in Greek tragedy and rhetoric.

EuripideanPolemic GreekDrama BookReview