Everything in This Country Must : Book Review

"Everything in This Country Must" by Colum McCann is a captivating collection of three emotionally charged stories that take place in Northern Ireland during the Troubles. This book delves deep into the effects of the conflict on individual lives and explores the intricate complexities of human relationships. McCann's writing is truly powerful, capturing the raw emotions and struggles of his characters with a poignant and beautifully crafted style.

The first story in the collection, "Everything in This Country Must," follows a young girl and her father who find themselves witnesses to a tragic incident involving a British Army helicopter. McCann masterfully portrays the profound impact this event has on their lives, leaving lasting scars that shape their experiences. Through this story, the themes of grief, loss, and the difficult choices individuals are forced to make in times of conflict are delicately explored.

In the second story, "Wood," McCann delves into the relationship between a teenage girl and her father, who have been displaced from their home due to the violence. The unwavering determination of the father to protect his daughter, coupled with their shared passion for horses, creates a narrative that is both tender and heart-wrenching. McCann effectively captures the resilience and spirit of individuals who manage to find flickers of hope amidst the chaos and uncertainty.

The final story, "Hunger Strike," focuses on the friendship between a young boy and an imprisoned IRA member who is on a hunger strike. McCann delves into the complexities of loyalty, sacrifice, and the conflicting emotions experienced by those caught up in the Troubles. This story shines a light on the profound impact of political decisions on the lives of ordinary people and the brutal consequences of violence.

Overall, "Everything in This Country Must" is a thought-provoking and deeply moving collection of stories that skillfully depicts the human side of the Troubles. McCann's mastery of storytelling and vivid imagery creates a compelling narrative that is both enlightening and unsettling. This book will resonate with readers interested in exploring the effects of political turmoil on individual lives and the universal themes of love, loss, and resilience.

What are readers saying?

"Everything in This Country Must" by Colum McCann has received a range of responses from readers. The book is composed of three stories that take place in Northern Ireland during the Troubles. Some readers praised McCann's writing style and his ability to capture the emotional impact of the conflict. However, others felt that the stories lacked depth and failed to make a lasting impression.

Many readers appreciated McCann's powerful and evocative writing, noting his skill in creating vivid imagery and conveying the essence of the characters and their experiences. They found the stories to be deeply moving, highlighting themes of loss, resilience, and the human connection. McCann's exploration of the Troubles added historical and political context to the narratives, making them more engaging for these readers.

However, a significant portion of reviewers felt that the stories lacked substance. They found the plots predictable and the characters underdeveloped. Some readers argued that the narratives did not explore the complexities of the conflict sufficiently, missing an opportunity to provide a nuanced understanding of the Troubles. They expressed disappointment that the stories did not leave a profound impact or provoke deeper thoughts and discussions.

Another common criticism was the brevity of the stories. Some readers felt that they ended abruptly and left them wanting more. They struggled to fully connect with the characters or become invested in their journeys due to the limited space for development and resolution.

Overall, "Everything in This Country Must" received a mix of positive and critical reviews. While many readers appreciated McCann's writing style and the themes explored in the book, others found the stories lacking in depth and impact. Ultimately, whether or not readers enjoy this collection may depend on their personal preferences for storytelling and their expectations for a thought-provoking exploration of the Troubles in Northern Ireland.

EverythingInThisCountryMust BookRecommendations IrishLiterature