Female Subjects in Black and White: Race, Psychoanalysis, Feminism : Book Review

"Female Subjects in Black and White" by Elizabeth Abel is a captivating exploration of the portrayal of black women in visual culture. The book examines various forms of art, including photography, film, and painting, to analyze how black women have been represented and commodified throughout history.

Abel begins by delving into the era of slavery, shedding light on the objectification and dehumanization of black women through visual depictions. She then moves on to analyze the impact of photography on racial and gender identities, highlighting the work of photographers such as Frances Benjamin Johnston and Carrie Mae Weems. Through her meticulous analysis, Abel uncovers how these photographers often portrayed black women as either symbols of racial pride or perpetuated harmful stereotypes.

The author also addresses the representation of black women in Hollywood films, discussing the limited roles available to black actresses and the hypersexualized stereotypes they were often subjected to. Abel challenges the notion of agency and self-representation, examining how black women have navigated their roles within the film industry.

Furthermore, Abel explores the depiction of black women in the art world, showcasing the works of artists like Mickalene Thomas and Lorna Simpson. These artists challenge traditional representations of black femininity, offering a powerful alternative to dominant narratives.

Overall, "Female Subjects in Black and White" is a well-researched and thought-provoking book that sheds light on the complex and problematic representation of black women throughout history. Abel's analysis provides valuable insights into how visual culture has both perpetuated stereotypes and provided avenues for subversion and empowerment. This book encourages readers to re-evaluate their understanding of race, gender, and the power dynamics within visual culture.

What are readers saying?

"Female Subjects in Black and White" is a thought-provoking book written by Elizabeth Abel that delves into the portrayal of women in visual culture. The book has received a mixture of reviews from readers, with some praising the author's insightful analysis while others believe it falls short in certain areas.

Many readers commend Elizabeth Abel for her extensive research and her ability to explore the complex issues surrounding the representation of women in art. They appreciate the book's in-depth analysis and thought-provoking arguments. It is praised for its ability to challenge conventional perspectives and shed light on how women have historically been depicted in black and white photography.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with the book's narrow focus, as it primarily examines early twentieth-century American photography. They argue that it lacks a broader international perspective on the representation of female subjects. Some readers also mention that the book can be dense and academic, which may make it inaccessible to those without a background in art or gender studies.

Another point of contention among reviewers is the book's use of images. While some appreciate the inclusion of photographs to support the author's arguments, others feel that the quality or integration of the images is lacking.

Furthermore, a few readers express concerns about the book's outdated nature, as it was originally published in 1993. They feel that it does not sufficiently address contemporary issues and developments in the representation of women in art.

FemaleSubjectsInBlackAndWhite WomenInLiterature GenderRepresentation