"Fifth Business" by Robertson Davies is an incredibly immersive and intricately woven novel that delves into the themes of identity, guilt, and the interconnectedness of our lives. The story is set in the small Canadian town of Deptford and centers around the life of Dunstan Ramsay, a man haunted by a childhood accident that shapes his destiny. As Ramsay reflects on his life, he discovers that he has always played the role of "fifth business," a supporting character in the lives of those around him. Through the skillful development of the characters and captivating storytelling, Davies challenges readers to contemplate their own place in the grand narrative of life.
One of the most compelling aspects of this novel is Davies' exceptional characterization. Each character is uniquely crafted, with their own fears, desires, and hidden truths. As Ramsay delves deeper into the lives of those he encounters, he uncovers a complex web of relationships, illustrating the intricate ways in which each person's story intertwines with another. Davies' meticulous attention to detail and psychological insight breathe life into these characters, immersing the reader in their experiences.
Furthermore, "Fifth Business" explores the lingering effects of guilt on Ramsay's life. His childhood accident weighs heavily on his conscience, burdening him with guilt and a sense of responsibility for the events that unfold. Through Ramsay's introspection, the novel poses thought-provoking questions about the nature of guilt, its ability to shape our lives, and the possibility of escaping its grasp.
Available on Audible
The exploration of identity is another noteworthy aspect of the novel. Ramsay's search for his own identity parallels a broader examination of how society labels and defines individuals. As Ramsay confronts the different roles he has fulfilled throughout his life, he is confronted with the question of his true purpose and identity in the larger narrative of existence.
Overall, "Fifth Business" is a masterfully crafted novel that engages readers on multiple levels. Through its vividly drawn characters, exploration of guilt and identity, and profound themes, Robertson Davies provides a captivating and introspective literary experience. This book is a must-read for those seeking a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant journey.
What are readers saying?
Robertson Davies' debut novel, "Fifth Business," has garnered a diverse array of reviews from readers. As the first installment in the "Deptford Trilogy," the book has received both acclaim and criticism for its intricate characters and thought-provoking themes.
Many reviewers applaud Davies for his masterful storytelling and vivid character development. They praise the depth and complexity of the protagonist, Dunstan Ramsay, and find themselves captivated by his journey from childhood to adulthood. Readers are particularly drawn to the exploration of identity, guilt, and the lasting influence of the past on the present. Additionally, the novel's historical backdrop, set against the tumultuous period of World War I and its aftermath, is lauded for its authenticity and detailed descriptions.
However, some readers express reservations about the book's pace and its level of accessibility. They feel that the numerous digressions and philosophical ponderings detract from the main plot, rendering the novel needlessly convoluted. Some readers also voice frustration over unresolved storylines and underdeveloped characters, believing that loose ends are left dangling.
The portrayal of female characters in "Fifth Business" has provoked mixed reactions from readers. While some appreciate the depth and complexity given to characters like Mary Dempster and Leola, others argue that they are primarily employed as plot devices or stereotypes. The treatment of women within the novel, with overarching themes of patriarchy and misogyny, is both commended for its candor and criticized for its lack of nuance and representativeness.
Davies' prose and writing style receive both accolades and grievances. Many readers admire his elegant and lyrical prose, which effectively captures the essence of the time period and enhances the portrayal of the characters. Nonetheless, some readers find the prose to be excessively dense, requiring additional effort to fully grasp the intended meaning.
FifthBusiness RobertsonDavies LiteraryClassic