Flaubert, Joyce and Beckett: The Stoic Comedians (Lannan Selection) : Book Review

Hugh Kenner's "Flaubert, Joyce, and Beckett" offers a captivating exploration of the connections and influences between these three giants of literature: Gustave Flaubert, James Joyce, and Samuel Beckett. Through a meticulous analysis of their writing styles, themes, and techniques, Kenner delves into the creative processes that revolutionized the art of fiction.

Kenner begins by examining Flaubert's profound impact on both Joyce and Beckett. He highlights Flaubert's meticulous attention to detail and his relentless pursuit of artistic perfection. This commitment to realism greatly influenced Joyce and Beckett in their own approaches to writing. Kenner carefully dissects the authors' engagement with language and their experimental use of form and narrative structure, revealing the intricate connections between their works.

But Kenner goes beyond simple comparisons. He delves into the philosophical underpinnings of their literature, exploring themes of alienation, existentialism, and the absurd that are prevalent in their respective bodies of work. Kenner offers profound insights into how each author grapples with questions of identity, meaning, and human existence, shedding light on their unique literary visions.

One of the strengths of Kenner's book is his ability to make complex ideas accessible to both scholars and general readers. He supports his analysis with ample examples and quotations from the authors' works, allowing readers to witness the connections and influences firsthand. The book is impeccably researched, drawing from a wide range of sources to provide a comprehensive overview of the lives and careers of these three literary figures.

"Flaubert, Joyce, and Beckett" is a highly enlightening and compelling read for anyone interested in these iconic writers. Kenner's deep understanding of their works, combined with his insightful analysis, offers a fresh perspective on their lasting literary legacies. Whether you are an academic or a general reader seeking a deeper appreciation of Flaubert, Joyce, and Beckett, this book is an essential addition to your reading list.

What are readers saying?

Hugh Kenner's book "Flaubert, Joyce and Beckett" has received a range of reviews, reflecting the varying opinions on its exploration of the works of these influential authors and their contributions to literature. This summary provides an overview of the feedback received.

On the positive side, many readers praised Kenner's insightful analysis and his deep understanding of the literary techniques employed by Flaubert, Joyce, and Beckett. They appreciated how the book sheds light on the connections and influences between these authors, offering valuable insights and interpretations. Furthermore, readers found Kenner's writing style engaging and accessible, making complicated literary concepts easier to comprehend.

However, not all reviews were favorable. Some readers felt that Kenner's book had an excessively academic and dense approach, making it difficult to grasp the core ideas being presented. They mentioned that the book delves too deeply into the technical aspects of literature, lacking a more enjoyable and relatable narrative. In addition, a few readers found the book to be repetitive, reiterating the same ideas without providing substantial new insights.

A recurring theme in the reviews was the comparison between the three authors – Flaubert, Joyce, and Beckett. Readers appreciated Kenner's ability to connect the dots and highlight the similarities and differences in their writing styles, themes, and techniques. Nevertheless, some readers thought these comparisons were subjective, wishing for a more objective analysis based on evidence.

The depth of analysis provided by Kenner was a point of contention among readers. While some appreciated the meticulous examination, others found it overwhelming and inaccessible. They felt that the book might be better suited for academics or experts in the field, rather than casual readers seeking a more general understanding of the three authors and their works.

FlaubertJoyceBeckett LiteraryMasters ModernistWriters