"For Her Own Good" by Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English is a thought-provoking exploration of the history of women and the societal expectations placed on them. The authors take a critical look at the oppressive practices that have restricted women throughout history and argue that many of these practices were disguised as means of protecting women's physical and mental health. They delve into various aspects of women's lives, examining their roles as wives and mothers, as well as the role of the medical and psychiatric fields in enforcing restrictive gender norms.
The book presents a compelling argument against the belief that women need to be controlled and protected for their own well-being. It sheds light on the ways in which women's autonomy and agency have been denied over time. Through historical examples and case studies, the authors illustrate the harmful consequences of these practices and challenge the authority of the medical profession in determining what is best for women. They expose the biases and limitations that have influenced medical treatments for women throughout history.
One of the striking aspects of "For Her Own Good" is its ability to highlight the ongoing societal pressure and expectations that continue to limit women's choices today. The book emphasizes the importance of questioning ingrained gender roles and challenging traditional narratives about women's roles in society. It urges readers to reevaluate the patriarchal systems that perpetuate these oppressive practices and recognize the impact they have on women's autonomy and well-being.
Available on Audible
Despite the heavy subject matter, the authors present their arguments in an engaging and accessible manner. They blend personal anecdotes, historical research, and cultural analysis to create a well-rounded and compelling narrative. The book serves as a wake-up call, prompting readers to consider the lasting effects of societal expectations and norms on women's lives.
Overall, "For Her Own Good" is a powerful and eye-opening read that challenges long-held beliefs about women's roles and advocates for necessary change. It encourages readers to critically examine the societal pressures placed on women and emphasizes the importance of reclaiming women's autonomy and agency.
What are readers saying?
Barbara Ehrenreich's book, "For Her Own Good," delves into the expectations imposed on women throughout history and their impact on their mental and physical well-being. This work has received a range of reviews from readers. Many commend Ehrenreich for her thorough research and attention to detail, which shed light on the challenges faced by women throughout time. They particularly praise her ability to present complex ideas in an accessible manner, making the book engaging and informative. Some readers find the book empowering and inspiring as it encourages women to question societal norms and forge their own paths.
However, some readers criticize "For Her Own Good" for being overly repetitive and lacking a clear focus. They believe the book could have been more concise and structured, as certain sections seem to repeat ideas and veer off from the main argument. Additionally, a few readers express disappointment with the lack of solutions or practical advice offered in the book.
Despite these mixed opinions, most readers agree that "For Her Own Good" is a valuable contribution to the discussion on women's issues. They appreciate how Ehrenreich challenges conventional views of femininity and highlights the harmful consequences of societal expectations. Furthermore, they see the book as a reminder that there is still progress to be made in terms of gender equality and the importance of supporting women's autonomy and well-being.
In summary, "For Her Own Good" receives positive reviews for its comprehensive research, insightful analysis, and thought-provoking content. While some critique its repetitive nature and absence of practical solutions, the majority of readers find value in Ehrenreich's exploration of the historical and societal pressures faced by women. This book serves as a call to action for readers to challenge harmful gender stereotypes and work towards a more equal and supportive society.