"For Her Own Good" by Barbara Ehrenreich takes readers on a captivating journey through the history and evolution of women's roles in society, specifically in relation to their health and well-being. Co-authored with Deirdre English, the book unveils the oppressive expectations and limitations imposed on women by exploring various cultural and historical contexts. Through meticulous research and insightful analysis, Ehrenreich and English expose the influential grip of patriarchal norms on women's lives and advocate for increased autonomy and freedom.
One significant theme explored in the book is the medicalization of women's bodies and emotions. The authors trace this phenomenon back to the Victorian era, where women's "hysteria" was regarded as a medical condition requiring treatment. By revealing the ways in which medicalization has often served to pathologize and control women's experiences, the authors illuminate the history of women being reduced to vessels to be managed and subdued.
The book also delves into the concept of "domesticity" and the expectations placed on women to embody the idealized image of the perfect wife and mother. Ehrenreich and English present compelling evidence that demonstrates the detrimental effects of this ideal, including the stifling of women's ambitions and desires, as well as their entrapment in an unending cycle of unpaid domestic labor.
Available on Audible
Furthermore, the authors examine the historical roots of the contemporary issue of body image and the pressure on women to conform to unrealistic beauty standards. By exploring the Victorian obsession with corsets and the subsequent rise of the beauty industry, Ehrenreich and English shed light on the long-standing commodification and scrutiny of women's bodies throughout history.
Ultimately, "For Her Own Good" champions a reevaluation of the societal expectations placed upon women and emphasizes the importance of recognizing their equal rights and autonomy. Ehrenreich and English challenge traditional narratives surrounding women's health and well-being, offering readers a fresh perspective on the history of women's oppression and the urgency of dismantling patriarchal structures. This thought-provoking book serves as a powerful call to action for a more inclusive and equitable society.
What are readers saying?
Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English's book "For Her Own Good" has garnered a wide range of opinions from readers. The book explores the historical impact of cultural expectations and medical practices on women's roles in society. Some reviewers found the book to be a thought-provoking and enlightening read. They appreciated the authors' in-depth research and analysis of how societal norms have reinforced the idea of women's submission and obedience. These readers found the book to be a valuable resource for understanding the historical context of women's struggle for autonomy and independence.
However, there were also readers who critiqued the book for its academic and dense writing style. They found it challenging to get through and believed that the authors could have made the book more engaging by incorporating personal anecdotes or contemporary examples. Additionally, some reviewers disagreed with the authors' assertions and thought that the book oversimplified certain issues, neglecting the complexities of historical and cultural contexts. Some readers also felt that the book was outdated, published in 1978, and failed to adequately address more recent developments in women's rights movements.
Despite the criticisms, several reviewers commended the book for shedding light on the societal pressures and expectations imposed on women, as well as the historical medical practices that often treated women as inferior and delicate. They appreciated the authors' exploration of childbirth, mental health, and sexuality, viewing the book as eye-opening and informative.
In conclusion, "For Her Own Good" by Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English has generated both praise and criticism from readers. While some individuals found it to be an informative and thought-provoking examination of women's history, others felt that it lacked in certain areas and had an overly scholarly approach. Nevertheless, the book remains a catalyst for important conversations surrounding gender roles and societal expectations.