Getting Even: Forgiveness and Its Limits : Book Review

"Getting Even: Revenge as a Form of Justice" by Jeffrie G. Murphy is a captivating and thought-provoking book that delves into the controversial topic of revenge and its potential as a form of justice. Murphy presents a compelling argument, challenging conventional ideas of punishment and retribution while exploring the philosophical and ethical aspects of revenge.

Murphy begins by examining the historical origins of revenge and acknowledges its negative connotations in modern society. However, he argues that revenge can also serve as a means to restore balance and rectify moral wrongs. Drawing on compelling examples and case studies, Murphy presents situations where revenge is seen as a just response to injustice.

Throughout the book, Murphy engages with various philosophical perspectives, such as retributivism and utilitarianism. He explores personal vendettas, legal systems, and societal norms, offering insightful critiques and suggestions for reform. This balanced approach allows readers to consider both the moral and practical implications of revenge as a form of justice.

A notable strength of "Getting Even" is Murphy's ability to present complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner. His writing style is engaging and persuasive, making it easy for readers to follow along and understand his arguments. Moreover, his balanced approach enhances the book's readability, as he considers both the benefits and potential pitfalls of embracing revenge as a form of justice.

In conclusion, "Getting Even: Revenge as a Form of Justice" is a captivating exploration of the concept of revenge and its potential as a form of justice. Jeffrie G. Murphy challenges prevailing notions of punishment and retribution, offering new perspectives and stimulating intellectual discussions. This book is a valuable resource for anyone interested in the philosophy of justice and ethics.

What are readers saying?

"Getting Even" by Jeffrie G. Murphy is a compilation of essays that delve into revenge from a philosophical and ethical perspective. The reception of the book has been varied among readers, with some applauding the author's thought-provoking arguments, while others criticize it for being repetitive and lacking depth.

One consistent theme in favorable reviews is the book's ability to stimulate critical thinking and engage readers in moral discussions. Murphy's exploration of revenge as a response to injustice and its role as a form of social control resonated with many. Readers found the insights into the complex relationship between revenge and justice to be enlightening and intellectually stimulating.

However, some readers found fault with the book, describing it as repetitious and lacking substance. They felt that the author rehashed the same arguments without presenting fresh perspectives or new insights. Additionally, certain readers felt the text was dense and overly academic, potentially alienating a broader audience.

On a positive note, a number of readers appreciated the author's use of real-life examples and case studies to illustrate his arguments. These examples effectively grounded the theoretical discussions and made them relatable. By incorporating historical and contemporary instances of revenge, the book provided depth and relevance to its arguments.

Conversely, some reviewers criticized the book for its convoluted language and dense writing style. They struggled to follow the author's arguments and suggested that clearer explanations and a more straightforward approach would have been beneficial. The lack of clear structure and organization was also mentioned as a drawback by some.

GettingEvenBook RevengeReads JusticeServed