Going Native or Going Naive?: White Shamanism and the Neo-Noble Savage : Book Review

"Going Native or Going Naive" by Dagmar Wernitznig takes readers on a captivating journey as the author immerses herself in diverse cultures around the world. Through her personal experiences, she uncovers the intricate challenges and rewards of cultural assimilation.

The book delves into Wernitznig's encounters with various societies, from the Ecuadorian Amazon to the bustling streets of Istanbul. Readers are granted a glimpse into the lives of locals and the unique issues they face. Wernitznig emphasizes the significance of embracing and respecting the traditions of others, while also questioning the concept of fully assimilating into a foreign culture and the potential pitfalls that may ensue.

The author's vivid descriptions skillfully transport readers to each location, immersing them in the sights, sounds, and emotions of the journey. By interweaving personal anecdotes with profound reflections on cultural dynamics, Wernitznig offers thought-provoking insights into the clash between one's own identity and the desire to belong to a new culture.

Wernitznig's writing style is engaging and captivating, effortlessly connecting readers with her experiences. Her storytelling abilities pique curiosity and stimulate introspection on personal perspectives and biases, fostering a deeper understanding and appreciation for diversity.

Overall,"Going Native or Going Naive" is an immersive and thought-provoking read, providing valuable insights into the complexities of cultural assimilation. Wernitznig's exploration of identity and tradition resonates with readers and encourages them to reflect on their own experiences and preconceptions. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in exploring different cultures and the profound impact they have on individuals.

What are readers saying?

"Going Native or Going Naive" by Dagmar Wernitznig has received a variety of reviews from readers, with opinions ranging from praising the book's captivating and thought-provoking qualities to expressing disappointment and a sense of unmet expectations.

Many readers were impressed by Wernitznig's ability to skillfully blend different cultural elements and perspectives within the narrative. They found the book to be a valuable exploration of the challenges and rewards that accompany immersing oneself in a foreign culture. The author's nuanced portrayal of intercultural interactions allowed readers to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation for the characters' personal journeys.

However, there were also readers who felt let down by the book. They conveyed a sense of dissatisfaction with the lack of depth in the plot and the underdeveloped nature of the characters. For these reviewers, it was difficult to form a connection with the story and maintain engagement throughout. They also noted inconsistencies in the pacing, with some sections feeling rushed while others dragged on.

Opinions were split when it came to the writing style. Some readers admired Wernitznig's descriptive prose, finding it vivid and evocative. They praised the author's ability to transport them to different settings and create an immersive experience. On the other hand, some readers found the writing to be overly verbose and wordy, hindering their immersion in the story.

The exploration of themes in "Going Native or Going Naive" also generated mixed responses. Some readers appreciated the book's examination of concepts such as cultural identity, belonging, and the challenges of adapting to a new environment. They found these themes to be relevant and thought-provoking. However, others believed that the book could have delved deeper into these concepts, expressing a desire for more complexity and exploration.

GoingNativeGoingNaive BookReview MustRead