Goldfish - a Philip Marlowe / Carmady Short Story (Philip Marlowe) : Book Review

"Goldfish - A Philip Marlowe/Carmady Short Story" by Raymond Chandler is an enthralling detective story that immerses readers in the captivating world of private investigator Philip Marlowe. Set in the vibrant and gritty backdrop of Los Angeles, the narrative revolves around Marlowe being hired by a troubled and wealthy man named Ralph Challis to gather information on his wife's enigmatic lover, Joe Carmady. As Marlowe digs deeper into the case, he unravels a complex network of deceit, secrets, and a potential murder.

Chandler's writing style perfectly matches the noir atmosphere of the story, combining eloquence with grit. The narrative is brimming with sharp dialogue, vivid descriptions, and an intense sense of suspense. From the bustling streets of Los Angeles to the dimly-lit hotel rooms, Chandler vividly portrays the city's underbelly.

The characters in "Goldfish" are multi-dimensional and captivating. Marlowe, the tough yet principled private detective, serves as the quintessential protagonist, captivating readers with his wit and sharp observations. Challis and Carmady are equally well-crafted characters, each harboring their own secrets and motivations that keep readers guessing until the thrilling finale.

One of the story's strengths is its ability to deliver a captivating mystery within a limited number of pages. Chandler skillfully weaves together diverse plot elements, incorporating twists and turns that ensure readers stay engaged. The pacing is brisk yet balanced, allowing the narrative to unfold organically.

Overall, "Goldfish - A Philip Marlowe/Carmady Short Story" is an exhilarating read for fans of Raymond Chandler's detective novels. With its masterful storytelling, memorable characters, and gripping mystery, this short story showcases Chandler's prowess as a writer.

What are readers saying?

Raymond Chandler's book, "Goldfish - A Philip Marlowe Carmady Short Story," has received mixed reviews from readers. Some reviewers praised the captivating storytelling and the iconic character of Philip Marlowe, while others found the story lacking depth and underwhelming.

Many reviewers applauded Chandler's engaging writing style, noting his descriptive prose that effortlessly captures the essence of the noir genre with its dark and gritty atmosphere. They commended his ability to build tension throughout the story, keeping readers immersed and captivated.

Philip Marlowe, the main character, received praise from numerous reviewers. They appreciated his witty dialogue and his tough yet vulnerable personality. Readers found him relatable and well-rounded, adding depth to the story. The dynamic and entertaining interactions between Marlowe and other characters were specifically highlighted.

However, some reviewers expressed disappointment with the brevity of the book. They felt the story was too short and left them wanting more. These readers desired a more complex plot and deeper character development that they felt was lacking in this short story.

Another criticism was directed at the predictability of the storyline. Some reviewers found the plot formulaic and lacking surprises. They had hoped for more twists and turns to keep them engaged until the very end.

GoldfishMystery PhilipMarlowe ShortStory