Gone to be a Soldier : Book Review

"Gone to be a Soldier" by Judy Raizor is an enthralling work of historical fiction that transports readers back to the tumultuous times of the American Civil War. Through the protagonist, Samuel Bird, we witness the challenges and sacrifices faced by soldiers in the 1860s.

The novel skillfully delves into the harsh realities of war, shedding light on the physical and emotional toll it takes on the soldiers. Raizor's vivid descriptions and attention to historical detail immerse the reader in the setting, from the brutal battle scenes to the moments of camaraderie among the soldiers. The author's meticulous research truly brings the Civil War era to life.

What sets "Gone to be a Soldier" apart is its strong character development. Samuel Bird is a relatable and multi-dimensional protagonist whose journey resonates with readers. His aspirations of becoming a teacher are put on hold as he feels compelled to enlist in the Union army out of a sense of duty and patriotism. Raizor portrays the complex relationships between Samuel and his comrades, showcasing the bonds forged in the face of adversity.

The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, seamlessly blending moments of intense action with quieter reflective periods. Raizor's engaging and accessible writing style allows readers to easily connect with the story and its characters. The authenticity of the novel is enhanced by the author's meticulous research, which creates an immersive reading experience.

In summary, "Gone to be a Soldier" is a captivating historical fiction novel that brings the American Civil War to life. Judy Raizor's compelling storyline, well-rounded characters, and attention to historical detail make it a must-read for fans of the genre. The novel's thought-provoking narrative will leave a lasting impression on readers, offering a deeper understanding of the sacrifices made during this pivotal period in American history.

What are readers saying?

Judy Raizor's novel, "Gone to be a Soldier," set during the American Civil War, has received a range of reviews from readers. It delves into the challenges and experiences faced by soldiers and their families during this turbulent period in history.

Some readers commended Raizor's descriptive writing style, noting its ability to transport readers back to the Civil War era. They appreciated the attention to detail and historical accuracy, which allowed them to fully immerse themselves in the story. Additionally, these readers enjoyed the well-developed characters and became deeply invested in their lives and struggles.

However, other readers expressed disappointment with the pacing of the novel, finding it slow at times, which made it difficult to maintain interest. Some reviewers also felt that the plot was predictable, lacking unexpected twists and turns. These readers were hoping for more suspense and excitement in the storytelling.

A common critique among readers was the lack of emotional depth in the characters. While some found the protagonists relatable and well-defined, others felt that their emotions and motivations were not fully explored. As a result, these readers felt disconnected from the characters and less invested in their journeys.

Additionally, some readers were dissatisfied with the overly simplified portrayal of the Civil War. They felt that Raizor's depiction of the conflict and its aftermath lacked nuance, focusing more on the romantic elements of the story rather than delving into the broader historical context.

GoneToBeASoldier BookLovers HistoricalNovel