Good Faith and Truthful Ignorance: A Case of Transatlantic Bigamy : Book Review

"Good Faith and Truthful Ignorance: A Case of Transatlantic Bigamy" by Alexandra Parma Cook is a captivating exploration of the intriguing life of Gonzalo Méndez de Canço, a Spanish Conquistador, and his intriguing dual marriages in 16th-century Mexico and Spain. Cook skillfully combines meticulous archival research with insightful anthropological analysis to unravel the complexities of this unique case while shedding light on the cultural, social, and legal aspects of transatlantic relationships during this era.

Through her thorough examination of court documents, letters, and other primary sources, Cook presents a rich and detailed account of Méndez de Canço's life and the circumstances surrounding his two marriages. With her keen eye for detail, the author paints a vivid picture of the colonial societies in which he lived, providing valuable insights into the legal systems and cultural norms that shaped these communities.

What makes this book stand out is Cook's exploration of the broader themes that emerge from this specific case, such as gender dynamics, religious influence, and racial considerations. She analyzes the different perspectives of the parties involved, shedding light on the power dynamics and social hierarchies at play. Additionally, the author delves into the role of Catholicism and the Catholic Church in the context of transatlantic marriages, offering a thought-provoking examination of the influence of religious institutions on personal and societal choices.

The narrative unfolds like a captivating detective story, keeping readers engaged and intrigued from start to finish. Cook's prose is both accessible and scholarly, making "Good Faith and Truthful Ignorance" an enjoyable read for both academic researchers and general history enthusiasts. By giving voice to the diverse individuals involved in this case, Cook provides readers with a nuanced understanding of the complexities and relationships that existed within the colonial context.

Overall, "Good Faith and Truthful Ignorance" is a meticulously researched and compelling account of a unique case of bigamy in the transatlantic world. Alexandra Parma Cook deftly combines historical analysis with anthropological insights, offering readers a deeper understanding of the social, legal, and cultural dynamics of colonial Mexico and Spain in the 16th century.

What are readers saying?

"Good Faith and Truthful Ignorance" by Alexandra Parma Cook offers a fresh and insightful perspective on the 16th-century Spanish conquest of the Americas. Through extensive research and analysis of primary sources, the author uncovers the personal narratives of both conquistadors and indigenous people, providing a comprehensive understanding of this complex historical period.

Critics have praised Cook for her meticulous research and in-depth examination of primary sources. They appreciate her ability to present historical events in a nuanced and accessible manner, making it easier for readers to grasp the intricacies of this significant time in history. Reviewers also commend Cook's storytelling skills, noting her vivid descriptions that bring the characters to life and allow readers to empathize with their experiences.

The book's balanced portrayal of the Spanish conquest has been well-received by reviewers. Cook does not shy away from highlighting both the triumphs and atrocities committed by the conquistadors, providing readers the opportunity to form their own opinions. This objective approach helps readers understand the complex motivations and beliefs that drove both the conquerors and the conquered.

Cook's exploration of indigenous perspectives has also been praised by reviewers. They appreciate her incorporation of indigenous voices, shedding light on the often overlooked narratives of the oppressed. By doing so, Cook provides a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of the Spanish conquest on different indigenous cultures.

Reviewers have also noted the book's well-organized structure. Cook presents historical events in a clear and logical manner, allowing readers to follow the narrative effortlessly. The inclusion of maps and illustrations further enhances the reader's understanding and immersion into the story.

GoodFaithAndTruthfulIgnorance SpanishColonialHistory ExploringConquistadors